Statistik / Bola Sepak / China. Liga Satu China / Guangxi Pingguo Haliao vs Hebei Kungfu

Guangxi Pingguo Haliao vs Hebei Kungfu Statistics & Analysis

Sep 06, 2026 - 11:30
0 1.29
1 1.31
xG Accuracy: 64%
Laman pertaruhan premium stake: pengguna baharu boleh guna kod promo FHn2uDc1. Daftar sekarang

Pasaran yang dijejaki vs hasil sepenuh masa

Setiap baris membandingkan model pra-perlawanan lean dengan keputusan sepenuh masa.

  • Pasaran Ramalan Hasilnya Hasil
  • Over / Under 2.5 Under 2.5 Under 2.5 (1 matlamat) ✔ Betul
  • Kedua-dua Pasukan Menjaringkan Gol BTTS Ya Tidak ✖ tak betul
  • 1X2 Hebei Kungfu Hebei Kungfu ✔ Betul
  • Cerapan skor tepat 1-1, 0-1, 1-0, 1-2, 2-1 0-1 ✔ Betul

Validation Report

Immutable Snapshot

Prediction Time: Aug 31, 2026 · 01:25 UTC Snapshot ID: dp-6326451

Closing Odds 1.52
AI Fair Odds —
CLV +0.0%
Final Result Hebei Kungfu win · Guangxi Pingguo Haliao 0–1 Hebei Kungfu
Prediction ✔ Correct
Decision Grade B-

Model Performance

This prediction contributes to:

  • Primary Bets ROI (180d): -100.0%

Intelijen pasaran

Bacaan selepas pilihan utama: bagaimana suapan penutup berprioriti bergerak berbanding model.

Ringkasan pasaran

Pasaran kekal stabil menjelang sepakan. Tiada anjakan implied ketara antara PRE30 dan PRE1 pada snapshot berprioriti.

Walaupun pergerakan lewat kecil, model masih menilai Lukis (1X2),Hebei Kungfu (1X2),Bawah 2.5 gol jauh melebihi implied snapshot penutupan — bacaan statik "model vs harga", bukan kejaran steam.

Model masih melebihi implied penutupan pada Hebei Kungfu (1X2) kira-kira 19.8 mata peratus — isyarat salah harga paling jelas pada halaman ini.

Model vs implied penutup

Pasaran Model % Implied penutup % Jurang (pp)
Guangxi Pingguo Haliao (1X2) 34.7 61.0 -26.3
Lukis (1X2) 29.7 23.2 +6.5
Hebei Kungfu (1X2) 35.6 15.8 +19.8
Lebih 2.5 gol 48.2 52.6 -4.4
Bawah 2.5 gol 51.8 47.4 +4.4
Apa maksudnya

Secara ringkas: model kira-kira 35.6% pada Hebei Kungfu (1X2), manakala snapshot penutup menunjukkan kira-kira 15.8%. Bezanya — kira-kira 19.8 mata peratus — ialah jurang model-vs-pasaran terbesar yang ditonjolkan di halaman ini.

Ringkas: "implied penutup" ialah kebarangkalian terbit daripada odds akhir yang ditangkap (selepas de-vig ringkas). "Jurang (pp)" = peratus model tolak implied tersebut, dalam mata peratus (pp).

Pergerakan garisan menjelang sepakan mula

Satu buku prioriti setiap snapshot (bukan semua). Laluan tangkapan: PRE30 → PRE1 · Buku: Pinnacle

Dalam kurungan pada lajur: Penutup = snapshot pertama tersedia ikut PRE1→PRE5→PRE10→PRE30; Awal = pertama dalam PRE30→PRE10→PRE5 yang berbeza daripada Penutup.

Odds terperinci dilipat di bawah — pergerakan implied (de-vig) boleh diabaikan.

Lihat jadual penuh baris demi baris
Pasaran Awal (PRE30) Penutup (PRE1) Δ tersirat (pp)
Guangxi Pingguo Haliao (1X2) 1.52 1.52 0.0
Lukis (1X2) 4.0 4.0 0.0
Hebei Kungfu (1X2) 5.89 5.89 0.0
Lebih 2.5 gol 1.81 1.81 0.0
Bawah 2.5 gol 2.01 2.01 0.0

Taklimat AI untuk perlawanan ini belum tersedia. Selepas naik taraf pelayan, jalankan semula “Batch generate odds” untuk menjana ringkasan.

View technical JSON
{
  "bundle_version": 1,
  "content_hash": "9aa341fcd2734645990fad0ad3a9869bb44fd179a21a189b5f786431e8eea647",
  "decision_algo_version": "2.5.0",
  "facts": {
    "ai_fp": {
      "away_predicted_xg": 1.31,
      "away_win_prob": 0.3564,
      "away_win_prob_posterior": null,
      "bayes_applied": 0,
      "btts_no_prob": 0.455,
      "btts_yes_prob": 0.546,
      "dc_rho": -0.13,
      "draw_prob": 0.2965,
      "draw_prob_posterior": null,
      "fair_odds_away": 2.81,
      "fair_odds_away_posterior": null,
      "fair_odds_draw": 3.37,
      "fair_odds_draw_posterior": null,
      "fair_odds_home": 2.88,
      "fair_odds_home_posterior": null,
      "home_predicted_xg": 1.29,
      "home_win_prob": 0.347,
      "home_win_prob_posterior": null,
      "over_25_prob": 0.482,
      "prediction_confidence": "very_low",
      "under_25_prob": 0.518
    },
    "api_prediction": {
      "advice": "Double chance : Guangxi Pingguo Haliao or draw",
      "main_pick_display": "No Strong Winner Bet",
      "percent_away": "10%",
      "percent_draw": "45%",
      "percent_home": "45%",
      "winner_name": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao"
    },
    "away_xg": 1.31,
    "betting_insight": {
      "bet_label": "Hebei Kungfu",
      "confidence": null,
      "main_pick_meta": {
        "confidence": "low",
        "display_text": "No Strong Winner Bet",
        "edge": 0.1984,
        "edge_gap": 0.0087,
        "market": "1X2",
        "market_prob": 0.1575,
        "model_prob": 0.3559,
        "pick_type": "no_strong",
        "probabilities": {
          "away": 35.6,
          "draw": 29.7,
          "home": 34.7
        },
        "reason": "No clear edge in 1X2 market",
        "selection": null,
        "selection_name": null
      },
      "market_comparison": [
        {
          "affi_link": "",
          "bookmaker_name": "Pinnacle",
          "odd": 5.89
        }
      ],
      "risk_color": null,
      "risk_key": null,
      "stacked_market": null,
      "value_bet": {
        "best_odds": 5.89,
        "bookmaker_id": 0,
        "bookmaker_name": "Pinnacle",
        "display_market": "Hebei Kungfu Win",
        "is_value": false,
        "label": "Away",
        "market_fair_odds": 6.35,
        "market_odds": 5.89,
        "model_odds": 2.81,
        "overround": 7.8,
        "prob_edge": 18.6,
        "value_pct": 109.6,
        "value_rating": "no_value"
      }
    },
    "betting_markets": {
      "btts": {
        "away_clean_sheet": 5,
        "away_failed_to_score": 9,
        "away_played": 21,
        "away_score_rate": 73.0,
        "home_clean_sheet": 7,
        "home_failed_to_score": 3,
        "home_played": 20,
        "home_score_rate": 72.5,
        "no_prob": 45.5,
        "pick": "Yes",
        "pick_prob": 54.5,
        "source": "xG_dc",
        "strong_pick": false,
        "yes_prob": 54.5
      },
      "correct_score": {
        "away_expected": 1.31,
        "home_expected": 1.29,
        "scores": [
          {
            "away": 1,
            "home": 1,
            "label": "1-1",
            "prob": 12.6
          },
          {
            "away": 1,
            "home": 0,
            "label": "0-1",
            "prob": 9.7
          },
          {
            "away": 0,
            "home": 1,
            "label": "1-0",
            "prob": 9.6
          },
          {
            "away": 2,
            "home": 1,
            "label": "1-2",
            "prob": 8.2
          },
          {
            "away": 1,
            "home": 2,
            "label": "2-1",
            "prob": 8.1
          }
        ],
        "source": "xG"
      },
      "double_chance": {
        "options": [
          {
            "key": "1X",
            "label": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao or Draw",
            "prob": 64.3
          },
          {
            "key": "12",
            "label": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao or Hebei Kungfu",
            "prob": 70.3
          },
          {
            "key": "X2",
            "label": "Draw or Hebei Kungfu",
            "prob": 65.2
          }
        ],
        "pick_key": "12",
        "pick_label": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao or Hebei Kungfu",
        "pick_prob": 70.3
      },
      "match_winner": {
        "away_pct": 35.6,
        "draw_pct": 29.6,
        "home_pct": 34.7,
        "lean_key": "away",
        "lean_label": "Hebei Kungfu"
      },
      "over_under": {
        "api_hint": null,
        "avg_total": 2.6,
        "away_avg_scored": 0.9,
        "confidence": "low",
        "home_avg_scored": 1.8,
        "over_prob": 48.2,
        "pick": "Under 2.5",
        "pick_prob": 51.8,
        "source": "xG_dc",
        "strong_pick": false,
        "total_expected": 2.6,
        "under_prob": 51.8
      },
      "prob_source": "poisson",
      "value_bet_enhanced": {
        "bookmaker_id": 0,
        "bookmaker_name": "Pinnacle",
        "edge": 109.7,
        "implied_prob": 17.0,
        "is_value": false,
        "label": "Away",
        "market": "Hebei Kungfu Win",
        "model_prob": 35.6,
        "odds": 5.89
      }
    },
    "closing_line_bundle": {
      "away_team": "Hebei Kungfu",
      "closing_1x2_probs_pct": {
        "away": 15.75,
        "draw": 23.2,
        "home": 61.05
      },
      "closing_bookmaker": "Pinnacle",
      "closing_capture": "PRE1",
      "closing_fetched_at": "2026-09-06 11:29:12",
      "early_bookmaker": "Pinnacle",
      "early_capture": "PRE30",
      "early_fetched_at": "2026-09-06 11:02:17",
      "has_data": true,
      "home_team": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao",
      "largest_move_kind": null,
      "max_abs_move_pp": 0.0,
      "model_vs_closing": [
        {
          "closing_implied_pct": 61.05,
          "gap_pp": -26.32,
          "kind": "1x2_h",
          "model_pct": 34.73
        },
        {
          "closing_implied_pct": 23.2,
          "gap_pp": 6.48,
          "kind": "1x2_d",
          "model_pct": 29.68
        },
        {
          "closing_implied_pct": 15.75,
          "gap_pp": 19.84,
          "kind": "1x2_a",
          "model_pct": 35.59
        },
        {
          "closing_implied_pct": 52.62,
          "gap_pp": -4.42,
          "kind": "ou_o",
          "model_pct": 48.2
        },
        {
          "closing_implied_pct": 47.38,
          "gap_pp": 4.42,
          "kind": "ou_u",
          "model_pct": 51.8
        }
      ],
      "movement": [
        {
          "closing": 1.52,
          "early": 1.52,
          "implied_closing_pct": 61.05,
          "implied_delta_pp": 0.0,
          "implied_early_pct": 61.05,
          "kind": "1x2_h"
        },
        {
          "closing": 4.0,
          "early": 4.0,
          "implied_closing_pct": 23.2,
          "implied_delta_pp": 0.0,
          "implied_early_pct": 23.2,
          "kind": "1x2_d"
        },
        {
          "closing": 5.89,
          "early": 5.89,
          "implied_closing_pct": 15.75,
          "implied_delta_pp": 0.0,
          "implied_early_pct": 15.75,
          "kind": "1x2_a"
        },
        {
          "closing": 1.81,
          "early": 1.81,
          "implied_closing_pct": 52.62,
          "implied_delta_pp": 0.0,
          "implied_early_pct": 52.62,
          "kind": "ou_o"
        },
        {
          "closing": 2.01,
          "early": 2.01,
          "implied_closing_pct": 47.38,
          "implied_delta_pp": 0.0,
          "implied_early_pct": 47.38,
          "kind": "ou_u"
        }
      ],
      "movement_negligible": true,
      "same_bookmaker": true,
      "top_value_gap": {
        "gap_pp": 19.8,
        "kind": "1x2_a"
      }
    },
    "correct_score_insight": {
      "best_value": null,
      "lean_card": {
        "diff_pp": 0.1,
        "ev": 0.008,
        "has_edge": true,
        "label": "1-1",
        "market_odds": 8.0,
        "market_prob": 0.125,
        "market_prob_pct": 12.5,
        "model_prob": 0.126,
        "model_prob_pct": 12.6,
        "n_bookmakers": 7,
        "status_key": "positive_edge"
      },
      "most_likely": {
        "label": "1-1",
        "prob": 12.6
      },
      "top5": [
        {
          "label": "1-1",
          "prob": 12.6
        },
        {
          "label": "0-1",
          "prob": 9.7
        },
        {
          "label": "1-0",
          "prob": 9.6
        },
        {
          "label": "1-2",
          "prob": 8.2
        },
        {
          "label": "2-1",
          "prob": 8.1
        }
      ]
    },
    "home_xg": 1.29,
    "homepage_pick": null,
    "market_cards": [
      {
        "authority_action": "wait",
        "authority_note": "Model validation or guard rules block actionable value signals.",
        "consensus_odds": 5.89,
        "decision": "value_bet",
        "disagreement_label": "Strong",
        "disagreement_level": "strong",
        "ev": 0.0921,
        "ev_available": true,
        "ev_display": {
          "capped": false,
          "raw_pct": 9.2,
          "text": "+9.2%"
        },
        "featured": true,
        "id": "1x2",
        "implied_prob": 0.1575,
        "is_extreme_disagreement": false,
        "max_ev": 0.0921,
        "max_ev_display": {
          "capped": false,
          "raw_pct": 9.2,
          "text": "+9.2%"
        },
        "model_prob": 0.3559,
        "raw_edge_display": "+19.8 percentage points",
        "raw_edge_pp": 19.8,
        "raw_signal_ev": 1.0963,
        "raw_signal_ev_display": "+109.6%",
        "show_primary_label": false,
        "side_label": "Hebei Kungfu",
        "sort_key": 10232.89,
        "tier": "best"
      },
      {
        "decision": "lean",
        "decision_layer": {
          "available": false
        },
        "ev_available": false,
        "ev_no": null,
        "ev_no_display": null,
        "ev_yes": null,
        "ev_yes_display": null,
        "featured": false,
        "id": "btts",
        "max_ev": null,
        "n_bookmakers": 0,
        "no_prob": 45.5,
        "sort_key": 4050.0,
        "tier": "lean",
        "value_side": "yes",
        "yes_prob": 54.5
      },
      {
        "decision": "no_bet",
        "decision_layer": {
          "available": false
        },
        "ev_available": false,
        "ev_over": null,
        "ev_over_display": null,
        "ev_under": null,
        "ev_under_display": null,
        "featured": false,
        "id": "ou_2_5",
        "max_ev": null,
        "n_bookmakers": 0,
        "over_prob": 48.2,
        "sort_key": 2050.0,
        "tier": "pass",
        "under_prob": 51.8,
        "value_side": "under"
      },
      {
        "featured": false,
        "id": "correct_score",
        "sort_key": 817.8,
        "tier": "risk",
        "top_label": "1-1",
        "top_prob": 12.6
      }
    ],
    "market_intelligence": {
      "betting_signal": {
        "alert_breadth": "7/11",
        "alert_breadth_note": "7/11 sportsbooks confirmed",
        "alert_move": "\u2191 +4.8%",
        "alert_team": "Hebei Kungfu",
        "alert_title": "Sharp Money Alert",
        "divergence_pp": 26.4,
        "has_alert": true,
        "hero_edge_pp": -26.35,
        "hero_label": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao",
        "market_prob_pct": 15.8,
        "market_team": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao",
        "model_prob_pct": 35.6,
        "model_team": "Hebei Kungfu",
        "show": true,
        "status_icon": "!",
        "status_key": "caution",
        "status_label": "Use caution",
        "status_line": "Use caution \u2014 signals are mixed",
        "steam_score": 41,
        "steam_subtitle": "Moderate sharp signal",
        "steam_tier": "B",
        "title": "Betting Signal"
      },
      "decision_chain": {
        "academy_links": [
          {
            "key": "market_disagree",
            "read_min": 5,
            "title": "When Should You Trust AI Over the Market?",
            "url": "/academy/ai-betting/when-should-you-trust-ai-over-the-market/en"
          },
          {
            "key": "steam",
            "read_min": 4,
            "title": "What Is a Steam Move?",
            "url": "/academy/betting-market/what-is-a-steam-move/en"
          },
          {
            "key": "clv_pending",
            "read_min": 3,
            "title": "Why CLV Matters More Than Win Rate",
            "url": "/academy/clv/why-clv-matters-more-than-win-rate/en"
          }
        ],
        "alignment": {
          "direction_aligned": false,
          "direction_key": "conflict",
          "gap_pp": 26.4,
          "key": "conflict",
          "label": "Disagree",
          "model_strong": false,
          "pricing_aligned": false,
          "pricing_key": "low",
          "probability_gap_pp": 26.4,
          "summary": "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu."
        },
        "authority": {
          "action": "wait",
          "alignment": {
            "direction_aligned": false,
            "direction_key": "conflict",
            "gap_pp": 26.4,
            "key": "conflict",
            "label": "Disagree",
            "model_strong": false,
            "pricing_aligned": false,
            "pricing_key": "low",
            "probability_gap_pp": 26.4,
            "summary": "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu."
          },
          "alignment_key": "conflict",
          "best_consensus_ev": 0.0921,
          "best_outlier_ev": 0.010964,
          "confidence_band": "Moderate\u2013Low",
          "decision_strength": 3.0,
          "decision_strength_v1": 3.0,
          "decision_strength_v2": 3.0,
          "decision_type": "VALUE_ALERT",
          "execution_confidence": 13,
          "extreme_disagreement": false,
          "final_verdict_audit": {
            "action": "Monitor closing market and validate with CLV.",
            "action_label": "Action",
            "decision": "Wait - No Primary Bet",
            "is_primary": false,
            "snapshot": "The Decision Model estimates Hebei Kungfu at 35.6%, compared with a no-vig market probability of 15.8%.",
            "why": [
              {
                "text": "Decision Model identifies Hebei Kungfu as the value side (35.6%)",
                "tone": "ok"
              },
              {
                "text": "Market pricing conflicts with the model lean",
                "tone": "bad"
              },
              {
                "text": "Model\u2013market disagreement blocks Primary sizing",
                "tone": "bad"
              },
              {
                "text": "Market quality / price reliability is insufficient for Primary",
                "tone": "bad"
              },
              {
                "text": "Model confidence reduced due to calibration uncertainty",
                "tone": "bad"
              }
            ],
            "why_label": "Decision Summary"
          },
          "gap_pp": 19.8,
          "gates_failed": [
            "Reliability below 65"
          ],
          "has_top_pick": true,
          "headline": "Wait - No Primary Bet",
          "hero_mode": "default",
          "icon": "\u23f8",
          "label": "Wait for validation",
          "market_signal": "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu.",
          "model_conflict_detail": null,
          "model_lean": "Hebei Kungfu",
          "no_primary_reasons": {
            "all_triggered": [
              "market_conflict",
              "market_quality",
              "calibration_risk"
            ],
            "calibration_mode": "soft",
            "codes": [
              "market_conflict",
              "market_quality"
            ],
            "label": "Reason",
            "other_factors": [
              {
                "code": "market_quality",
                "detail": "Price reliability is weak (thin coverage, outlier quote, or low book agreement).",
                "name": "Market Quality Risk",
                "short": "Market Quality Risk",
                "tone": "warn"
              }
            ],
            "other_label": "Other factors",
            "primary": {
              "code": "market_conflict",
              "detail": "Model lean and market pricing / drift are not aligned.",
              "name": "Market Conflict",
              "short": "Market Conflict",
              "subtype": "drift_against_model",
              "tone": "warn"
            },
            "secondary": {
              "code": "market_quality",
              "detail": "Price reliability is weak (thin coverage, outlier quote, or low book agreement).",
              "name": "Market Quality Risk",
              "short": "Market Quality Risk",
              "tone": "warn"
            },
            "version": "v1"
          },
          "outlier_detected": false,
          "outlier_excluded_panel": "",
          "primary_allowed": false,
          "primary_block_explain": {
            "entries": [
              {
                "key": "positive_ev",
                "label": "Consensus EV +9.2% meets Primary gate (\u2265+5.0%)",
                "ok": true
              },
              {
                "key": "gate",
                "label": "Reliability below 65",
                "ok": false
              }
            ],
            "lean_ev_threshold_pct": 2.0,
            "primary_ev_threshold_pct": 5.0,
            "subtitle": "Primary needs consensus EV \u2265 +5.0% plus reliability/execution/calibration gates (Decision Strength is explain-only). Lean/tracked gate is +2.0% (selective only \u2014 not default Primary sizing).",
            "title": "Why not Primary?"
          },
          "primary_gate_checklist": "Gate checklist: Consensus EV +9.2% \u2705 (need \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration See checklist \u274c \u2192 Primary blocked. Decision Strength 3.0/10 (explain only, not a Primary gate). If you still act under hard block: example stake 0.10\u20130.20% bankroll (never Primary).",
          "primary_gate_snapshot": "Primary Gate Snapshot: Consensus EV +9.2% (gate \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration: See checklist \u2192 Primary blocked \u00b7 Decision Strength 3.0/10 (display only)",
          "primary_gates": {
            "items": [
              {
                "key": "extreme_gap",
                "label": "Extreme gap",
                "ok": true,
                "value": "no"
              },
              {
                "key": "xg_calibration",
                "label": "xG calibration",
                "ok": true,
                "value": "warning"
              },
              {
                "key": "reliability",
                "label": "Rel",
                "ok": false,
                "value": "49 (\u226565)"
              },
              {
                "key": "execution",
                "label": "Exec",
                "ok": false,
                "value": "13 (\u226565)"
              },
              {
                "key": "alignment",
                "label": "Align",
                "ok": false,
                "value": "conflict"
              },
              {
                "key": "consensus_ev",
                "label": "ConsEV",
                "ok": true,
                "value": "+9.2% (\u2265+5.0%)"
              },
              {
                "key": "top_pick",
                "label": "Pick",
                "ok": true,
                "value": "true"
              },
              {
                "key": "validation",
                "label": "Validation",
                "ok": false,
                "value": "false"
              }
            ],
            "passed": 4,
            "total": 8
          },
          "primary_type": null,
          "reasons": [
            "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu.",
            "Decision strength: 3.0/10",
            "Reliability below 65"
          ],
          "reliability_score": 49,
          "speed_read": "Speed read: Model Signal can look moderate/strong while Decision Strength stays low after calibration \u2014 Strength alone does not block Primary (v2.5+); still check reliability/execution/EV hard gates.",
          "strength_v2_breakdown": [
            "Base decision score (v1)",
            "Market steam conflicts with model",
            "Consensus-line +EV",
            "Low xG separation (league-average noise)"
          ],
          "subline": "Model validation or guard rules block actionable value signals.",
          "thresholds": {
            "extreme_gap_pp": 30.0,
            "lean_min_consensus_ev": 0.02,
            "lean_min_strength": 5.0,
            "min_consensus_ev": 0.05,
            "min_execution": 65,
            "min_reliability": 65,
            "min_strength": 7.0,
            "source": "db",
            "user_id": 2
          },
          "thresholds_source": "db",
          "thresholds_user_id": 2,
          "tier": "wait",
          "validation_ok": false,
          "value_context": {
            "consensus_ev": 0.0921,
            "consensus_ev_display": "+9.2%",
            "consensus_odds": 5.89,
            "disagreement_label": "Strong",
            "disagreement_level": "strong",
            "implied_prob": 0.1575,
            "is_extreme_disagreement": false,
            "model_prob": 0.3559,
            "raw_edge_display": "+19.8 percentage points",
            "raw_edge_pp": 19.8,
            "raw_implied_prob": 0.16977928692699493,
            "raw_signal_ev": 1.0963,
            "raw_signal_ev_display": "+109.6%"
          },
          "version": "v2.5",
          "xg_calibration": {
            "block_value_alert": true,
            "calibration_status": "warning",
            "deviation_pct": -3.0,
            "reasons": [
              "Low xG separation gap=0.02 (noise / no edge)"
            ],
            "recommended_action": "monitor",
            "strength_delta": -2.0,
            "uplift_away": null,
            "uplift_home": null,
            "xg_separation": {
              "band": "flat",
              "block_value_alert": true,
              "separation_score": -20,
              "strength_delta": -2.0,
              "xg_gap": 0.02
            }
          }
        },
        "bet_status": "wait",
        "books_breadth_display": "7/11",
        "breadth_ratio": 0.6363636363636364,
        "evidence": {
          "score": 57,
          "signals": [
            {
              "icon": "\u25cb",
              "key": "statistical_edge",
              "label": "No strong statistical edge",
              "status": "neutral"
            },
            {
              "icon": "!",
              "key": "market_agreement",
              "label": "Recent market move conflicts with the model favourite",
              "status": "caution"
            },
            {
              "icon": "!",
              "key": "steam",
              "label": "Market drift conflicts with model",
              "status": "caution"
            },
            {
              "icon": "!",
              "key": "validation",
              "label": "Validation warning",
              "status": "caution"
            }
          ],
          "stars": 2,
          "tier": "moderate",
          "tier_label": "Moderate"
        },
        "forecast_reliability": {
          "breakdown": [
            {
              "key": "validation",
              "label": "Validation: Warning",
              "tone": "caution"
            },
            {
              "key": "gap",
              "label": "Large market gap (26 pp)",
              "tone": "caution"
            },
            {
              "key": "steam",
              "label": "Market drift conflicts with model",
              "tone": "caution"
            }
          ],
          "parts": {
            "alignment": 11.8,
            "data_quality": 12.0,
            "market_coverage": 6.4,
            "steam_coherence": 0.0,
            "validation": 14.0
          },
          "score": 49,
          "stars": 2,
          "tier": "moderate",
          "tier_label": "Moderate"
        },
        "lean_gap_pp": 26.35,
        "market_agreement": "weak",
        "max_gap_pp": 26.35,
        "model_calibration": {
          "away_xg": 1.31,
          "calibration_status": "ok",
          "deviation_pct": -3.0,
          "elevated": false,
          "home_xg": 1.29,
          "impact_note": "",
          "league_avg_xg": 1.35,
          "peak_xg": 1.31,
          "status_label": "Within typical league range",
          "summary": "Home xG 1.29 \u00b7 Away xG 1.31 \u00b7 League avg 1.35 \u00b7 Peak deviation -3%",
          "title": "Model Calibration Check"
        },
        "move_is_drift": true,
        "mv_status": "warning",
        "odds_delta_pct": 4.8,
        "steam_conflicts": true,
        "steam_move_display": "\u2191 +4.8%",
        "steam_team": "Hebei Kungfu",
        "suppress_execution": true,
        "value_split": {
          "execution_confidence": {
            "label": "Monitoring Confidence",
            "score": 13,
            "tier": "not_reliable",
            "tier_label": "Not reliable"
          },
          "market_compatibility": {
            "label": "Pricing proximity (inverse gap)",
            "note": "This score falls as the probability gap (pp) rises \u2014 it is NOT a bet green light. Direction may still agree (see Alignment above). Formula: proximity = max(0, 100 \u2212 5\u00d7pp). Example: 16 pp \u2192 20/100 (diverged).",
            "score": 0,
            "tier": "not_reliable",
            "tier_label": "Not reliable"
          },
          "model_edge_strength": {
            "label": "Model Signal Strength",
            "score": 40,
            "tier": "low",
            "tier_label": "Low"
          },
          "model_value": {
            "label": "Pricing proximity (inverse gap)",
            "note": "This score falls as the probability gap (pp) rises \u2014 it is NOT a bet green light. Direction may still agree (see Alignment above). Formula: proximity = max(0, 100 \u2212 5\u00d7pp). Example: 16 pp \u2192 20/100 (diverged).",
            "score": 0,
            "tier": "not_reliable",
            "tier_label": "Not reliable"
          },
          "recommendation": {
            "action": "wait",
            "label": "Wait - No Primary Bet"
          }
        },
        "verdict": {
          "agree_note": "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu.",
          "alignment": {
            "direction_aligned": false,
            "direction_key": "conflict",
            "gap_pp": 26.4,
            "key": "conflict",
            "label": "Disagree",
            "model_strong": false,
            "pricing_aligned": false,
            "pricing_key": "low",
            "probability_gap_pp": 26.4,
            "summary": "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu."
          },
          "authority": {
            "action": "wait",
            "alignment": {
              "direction_aligned": false,
              "direction_key": "conflict",
              "gap_pp": 26.4,
              "key": "conflict",
              "label": "Disagree",
              "model_strong": false,
              "pricing_aligned": false,
              "pricing_key": "low",
              "probability_gap_pp": 26.4,
              "summary": "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu."
            },
            "alignment_key": "conflict",
            "best_consensus_ev": 0.0921,
            "best_outlier_ev": 0.010964,
            "confidence_band": "Moderate\u2013Low",
            "decision_strength": 3.0,
            "decision_strength_v1": 3.0,
            "decision_strength_v2": 3.0,
            "decision_type": "VALUE_ALERT",
            "execution_confidence": 13,
            "extreme_disagreement": false,
            "final_verdict_audit": {
              "action": "Monitor closing market and validate with CLV.",
              "action_label": "Action",
              "decision": "Wait - No Primary Bet",
              "is_primary": false,
              "snapshot": "The Decision Model estimates Hebei Kungfu at 35.6%, compared with a no-vig market probability of 15.8%.",
              "why": [
                {
                  "text": "Decision Model identifies Hebei Kungfu as the value side (35.6%)",
                  "tone": "ok"
                },
                {
                  "text": "Market pricing conflicts with the model lean",
                  "tone": "bad"
                },
                {
                  "text": "Model\u2013market disagreement blocks Primary sizing",
                  "tone": "bad"
                },
                {
                  "text": "Market quality / price reliability is insufficient for Primary",
                  "tone": "bad"
                },
                {
                  "text": "Model confidence reduced due to calibration uncertainty",
                  "tone": "bad"
                }
              ],
              "why_label": "Decision Summary"
            },
            "gap_pp": 19.8,
            "gates_failed": [
              "Reliability below 65"
            ],
            "has_top_pick": true,
            "headline": "Wait - No Primary Bet",
            "hero_mode": "default",
            "icon": "\u23f8",
            "label": "Wait for validation",
            "market_signal": "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu.",
            "model_conflict_detail": null,
            "model_lean": "Hebei Kungfu",
            "no_primary_reasons": {
              "all_triggered": [
                "market_conflict",
                "market_quality",
                "calibration_risk"
              ],
              "calibration_mode": "soft",
              "codes": [
                "market_conflict",
                "market_quality"
              ],
              "label": "Reason",
              "other_factors": [
                {
                  "code": "market_quality",
                  "detail": "Price reliability is weak (thin coverage, outlier quote, or low book agreement).",
                  "name": "Market Quality Risk",
                  "short": "Market Quality Risk",
                  "tone": "warn"
                }
              ],
              "other_label": "Other factors",
              "primary": {
                "code": "market_conflict",
                "detail": "Model lean and market pricing / drift are not aligned.",
                "name": "Market Conflict",
                "short": "Market Conflict",
                "subtype": "drift_against_model",
                "tone": "warn"
              },
              "secondary": {
                "code": "market_quality",
                "detail": "Price reliability is weak (thin coverage, outlier quote, or low book agreement).",
                "name": "Market Quality Risk",
                "short": "Market Quality Risk",
                "tone": "warn"
              },
              "version": "v1"
            },
            "outlier_detected": false,
            "outlier_excluded_panel": "",
            "primary_allowed": false,
            "primary_block_explain": {
              "entries": [
                {
                  "key": "positive_ev",
                  "label": "Consensus EV +9.2% meets Primary gate (\u2265+5.0%)",
                  "ok": true
                },
                {
                  "key": "gate",
                  "label": "Reliability below 65",
                  "ok": false
                }
              ],
              "lean_ev_threshold_pct": 2.0,
              "primary_ev_threshold_pct": 5.0,
              "subtitle": "Primary needs consensus EV \u2265 +5.0% plus reliability/execution/calibration gates (Decision Strength is explain-only). Lean/tracked gate is +2.0% (selective only \u2014 not default Primary sizing).",
              "title": "Why not Primary?"
            },
            "primary_gate_checklist": "Gate checklist: Consensus EV +9.2% \u2705 (need \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration See checklist \u274c \u2192 Primary blocked. Decision Strength 3.0/10 (explain only, not a Primary gate). If you still act under hard block: example stake 0.10\u20130.20% bankroll (never Primary).",
            "primary_gate_snapshot": "Primary Gate Snapshot: Consensus EV +9.2% (gate \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration: See checklist \u2192 Primary blocked \u00b7 Decision Strength 3.0/10 (display only)",
            "primary_gates": {
              "items": [
                {
                  "key": "extreme_gap",
                  "label": "Extreme gap",
                  "ok": true,
                  "value": "no"
                },
                {
                  "key": "xg_calibration",
                  "label": "xG calibration",
                  "ok": true,
                  "value": "warning"
                },
                {
                  "key": "reliability",
                  "label": "Rel",
                  "ok": false,
                  "value": "49 (\u226565)"
                },
                {
                  "key": "execution",
                  "label": "Exec",
                  "ok": false,
                  "value": "13 (\u226565)"
                },
                {
                  "key": "alignment",
                  "label": "Align",
                  "ok": false,
                  "value": "conflict"
                },
                {
                  "key": "consensus_ev",
                  "label": "ConsEV",
                  "ok": true,
                  "value": "+9.2% (\u2265+5.0%)"
                },
                {
                  "key": "top_pick",
                  "label": "Pick",
                  "ok": true,
                  "value": "true"
                },
                {
                  "key": "validation",
                  "label": "Validation",
                  "ok": false,
                  "value": "false"
                }
              ],
              "passed": 4,
              "total": 8
            },
            "primary_type": null,
            "reasons": [
              "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu.",
              "Decision strength: 3.0/10",
              "Reliability below 65"
            ],
            "reliability_score": 49,
            "speed_read": "Speed read: Model Signal can look moderate/strong while Decision Strength stays low after calibration \u2014 Strength alone does not block Primary (v2.5+); still check reliability/execution/EV hard gates.",
            "strength_v2_breakdown": [
              "Base decision score (v1)",
              "Market steam conflicts with model",
              "Consensus-line +EV",
              "Low xG separation (league-average noise)"
            ],
            "subline": "Model validation or guard rules block actionable value signals.",
            "thresholds": {
              "extreme_gap_pp": 30.0,
              "lean_min_consensus_ev": 0.02,
              "lean_min_strength": 5.0,
              "min_consensus_ev": 0.05,
              "min_execution": 65,
              "min_reliability": 65,
              "min_strength": 7.0,
              "source": "db",
              "user_id": 2
            },
            "thresholds_source": "db",
            "thresholds_user_id": 2,
            "tier": "wait",
            "validation_ok": false,
            "value_context": {
              "consensus_ev": 0.0921,
              "consensus_ev_display": "+9.2%",
              "consensus_odds": 5.89,
              "disagreement_label": "Strong",
              "disagreement_level": "strong",
              "implied_prob": 0.1575,
              "is_extreme_disagreement": false,
              "model_prob": 0.3559,
              "raw_edge_display": "+19.8 percentage points",
              "raw_edge_pp": 19.8,
              "raw_implied_prob": 0.16977928692699493,
              "raw_signal_ev": 1.0963,
              "raw_signal_ev_display": "+109.6%"
            },
            "version": "v2.5",
            "xg_calibration": {
              "block_value_alert": true,
              "calibration_status": "warning",
              "deviation_pct": -3.0,
              "reasons": [
                "Low xG separation gap=0.02 (noise / no edge)"
              ],
              "recommended_action": "monitor",
              "strength_delta": -2.0,
              "uplift_away": null,
              "uplift_home": null,
              "xg_separation": {
                "band": "flat",
                "block_value_alert": true,
                "separation_score": -20,
                "strength_delta": -2.0,
                "xg_gap": 0.02
              }
            }
          },
          "headline": "Wait - No Primary Bet",
          "icon": "\u23f8",
          "label": "Wait for validation",
          "subline": "Model validation or guard rules block actionable value signals.",
          "tier": "wait"
        },
        "why": {
          "action_line": "Compare model lean with current best odds before sizing any bet.",
          "bullets": [
            "Model: Guangxi Pingguo Haliao 1.29 xG vs Hebei Kungfu 1.31 \u2192 Hebei Kungfu 35.6%",
            "Market: Guangxi Pingguo Haliao ~15.8% implied",
            "Market Drift: Hebei Kungfu odds \u2191 +4.8%"
          ],
          "one_liner": "Model favours Hebei Kungfu, but the market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu.",
          "title": "Why?"
        }
      },
      "edge_rows": [
        {
          "edge_pp": -26.35,
          "fair_prob": 34.7,
          "label": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao",
          "market_prob": 61.05,
          "market_type": "1x2",
          "outcome": "home"
        },
        {
          "edge_pp": 6.45,
          "fair_prob": 29.65,
          "label": "Draw",
          "market_prob": 23.2,
          "market_type": "1x2",
          "outcome": "draw"
        },
        {
          "edge_pp": 19.89,
          "fair_prob": 35.64,
          "label": "Hebei Kungfu",
          "market_prob": 15.75,
          "market_type": "1x2",
          "outcome": "away"
        },
        {
          "edge_pp": null,
          "fair_prob": 48.2,
          "label": "Over 2.5",
          "market_prob": null,
          "market_type": "ou25",
          "outcome": "over"
        },
        {
          "edge_pp": null,
          "fair_prob": 51.8,
          "label": "Under 2.5",
          "market_prob": null,
          "market_type": "ou25",
          "outcome": "under"
        },
        {
          "edge_pp": null,
          "fair_prob": 54.5,
          "label": "BTTS Yes",
          "market_prob": null,
          "market_type": "btts",
          "outcome": "yes"
        },
        {
          "edge_pp": null,
          "fair_prob": 45.5,
          "label": "BTTS No",
          "market_prob": null,
          "market_type": "btts",
          "outcome": "no"
        }
      ],
      "edge_snapshot": {
        "edge_label": "extreme_disagreement",
        "edge_pp": -26.35,
        "fair_prob_pct": 34.7,
        "hero_side": "home",
        "hero_team_name": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao",
        "market_prob_pct": 61.05,
        "status": "strong_market_ahead",
        "steam_team_name": "Hebei Kungfu"
      },
      "fair_source": "poisson_pipeline",
      "fair_vs_market": {
        "closing_capture": "PRE1",
        "closing_footnote": "Model probabilities are generated from the statistical xG model using a Poisson distribution. Closing market probabilities are derived from consensus closing 1X2 odds after margin removal. Values represent implied probabilities rather than betting recommendations. Closing snapshot: PRE1.",
        "comparison_available": true,
        "comparison_disabled": false,
        "comparison_summary": "The closing market estimates Guangxi Pingguo Haliao\u0027s win probability at 61.0%, compared with the model\u0027s estimate of 34.7%, a difference of 26.4 percentage points. This highlights a disagreement between the model and market consensus, without indicating which view is ultimately correct.",
        "degraded_note": "",
        "divergence_guard": {
          "divergence_level": "extreme",
          "edge_status": "strong_market_ahead",
          "max_gap_pp": 26.35,
          "suppress_hero": false,
          "suppress_value_language": true
        },
        "divergence_label": "Extreme model-market divergence",
        "divergence_level": "extreme",
        "divergence_level_label": "Extreme divergence",
        "divergence_note": "The fair estimate differs substantially from current market pricing. Large divergences can occur when rating inputs are incomplete, team-strength estimates are uncertain, or the market incorporates information not present in the model. Interpret with caution.",
        "divergence_tier": "extreme",
        "edge_label": "Extreme disagreement",
        "edge_label_key": "extreme_disagreement",
        "fair_confidence": "medium",
        "fair_confidence_label": "Medium",
        "fair_source_note": "Model probabilities are generated from the statistical xG model using a Poisson distribution. Closing market probabilities are derived from consensus closing 1X2 odds after margin removal. Values represent implied probabilities rather than betting recommendations. Closing snapshot: PRE1.",
        "forecast_assessment": {
          "favourite_class": "Balanced match",
          "favourite_label": "Hebei Kungfu",
          "forecast_certainty_tier": "low",
          "headline": "Balanced match",
          "market_agreement_label": "Weak",
          "market_direction": {
            "label": "Conflicts with model",
            "positive": false
          },
          "market_prob_pct": 15.8,
          "model_prob_gap_display": "+19.8 percentage points",
          "model_prob_gap_pp": 19.8,
          "model_prob_pct": 35.6,
          "outcome_separation_tier": "low",
          "paragraphs": [],
          "pricing_convergence": {
            "gap_display": "+19.8 percentage points",
            "gap_pp": 19.8,
            "label": "Low convergence",
            "label_key": "mi_fa_pricing_low"
          },
          "reliability_headline": "Limited reliability",
          "reliability_icon": "!",
          "reliability_score": 49,
          "reliability_tier": "limited",
          "summary": "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu. This disagreement reduces confidence and prevents a Primary bet.",
          "tier": "balanced",
          "title": "Prediction Assessment",
          "validation_label": "Warning",
          "value_split": {
            "execution_confidence": {
              "label": "Monitoring Confidence",
              "score": 13,
              "tier": "not_reliable",
              "tier_label": "Not reliable"
            },
            "market_compatibility": {
              "label": "Pricing proximity (inverse gap)",
              "note": "This score falls as the probability gap (pp) rises \u2014 it is NOT a bet green light. Direction may still agree (see Alignment above). Formula: proximity = max(0, 100 \u2212 5\u00d7pp). Example: 16 pp \u2192 20/100 (diverged).",
              "score": 0,
              "tier": "not_reliable",
              "tier_label": "Not reliable"
            },
            "model_edge_strength": {
              "label": "Model Signal Strength",
              "score": 40,
              "tier": "low",
              "tier_label": "Low"
            },
            "model_value": {
              "label": "Pricing proximity (inverse gap)",
              "note": "This score falls as the probability gap (pp) rises \u2014 it is NOT a bet green light. Direction may still agree (see Alignment above). Formula: proximity = max(0, 100 \u2212 5\u00d7pp). Example: 16 pp \u2192 20/100 (diverged).",
              "score": 0,
              "tier": "not_reliable",
              "tier_label": "Not reliable"
            },
            "recommendation": {
              "action": "wait",
              "label": "Wait - No Primary Bet"
            }
          },
          "why": {
            "action_line": "Compare model lean with current best odds before sizing any bet.",
            "bullets": [
              "Model: Guangxi Pingguo Haliao 1.29 xG vs Hebei Kungfu 1.31 \u2192 Hebei Kungfu 35.6%",
              "Market: Guangxi Pingguo Haliao ~15.8% implied",
              "Market Drift: Hebei Kungfu odds \u2191 +4.8%"
            ],
            "one_liner": "Model favours Hebei Kungfu, but the market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu.",
            "title": "Why?"
          }
        },
        "forecast_certainty": {
          "note": "Three outcomes remain closely bunched \u2014 treat as a relatively open match.",
          "tier": "low",
          "tier_label": "Low"
        },
        "forecast_certainty_label": "Low",
        "has_market_probs": true,
        "hero_edge_pp": -26.35,
        "hero_label": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao",
        "hero_side": "home",
        "market_activity": "Hebei Kungfu odds lengthened \u2191 +4.8%.",
        "market_agreement": "weak",
        "market_agreement_label": "Weak",
        "market_interpretation": {},
        "market_narrative": {},
        "market_source": "closing_1x2",
        "max_gap_pp": 26.35,
        "model_validation": {
          "score_label_key": "mi_mv_warning",
          "status": "warning"
        },
        "model_validation_label": "Warning",
        "outcome_separation": {
          "breakdown": [
            "No outcome exceeds 50% on the 1X2 grid.",
            "Top two 1X2 outcomes within 0.9 percentage points."
          ],
          "lead_gap_pp": 0.9,
          "max_prob_pct": 35.6,
          "note": "How spread out the model 1X2 probabilities are \u2014 crowded splits mean no single outcome dominates. Not accuracy vs the market.",
          "tier": "low",
          "tier_label": "Low"
        },
        "outcome_separation_label": "Low",
        "overall_assessment": {
          "badge_class": "extreme",
          "largest_gap_label": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao",
          "largest_gap_pp": -26.4,
          "lead": "The closing market prices Guangxi Pingguo Haliao higher than the statistical model.",
          "level": "extreme",
          "max_gap_pp": 26.4,
          "title": "Strong Disagreement"
        },
        "rows": [
          {
            "difference_pp": -26.35,
            "edge_pp": -26.35,
            "fair_prob_pct": 34.7,
            "is_hero": true,
            "label": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao",
            "market_prob_pct": 61.05,
            "side": "home",
            "signal_key": "market_higher",
            "signal_label": "Market Higher"
          },
          {
            "difference_pp": 6.45,
            "edge_pp": 6.45,
            "fair_prob_pct": 29.65,
            "is_hero": false,
            "label": "Draw",
            "market_prob_pct": 23.2,
            "side": "draw",
            "signal_key": "model_higher",
            "signal_label": "Model Higher"
          },
          {
            "difference_pp": 19.89,
            "edge_pp": 19.89,
            "fair_prob_pct": 35.64,
            "is_hero": false,
            "label": "Hebei Kungfu",
            "market_prob_pct": 15.75,
            "side": "away",
            "signal_key": "model_edge",
            "signal_label": "Model Edge"
          }
        ],
        "status": "strong_market_ahead",
        "status_label": "Strong Market Ahead",
        "steam_note": "",
        "unavailable_note": ""
      },
      "interpretation": {
        "has_conflict": true,
        "paragraphs": [
          "The betting market strongly prefers Guangxi Pingguo Haliao (15.8%).",
          "Hebei Kungfu odds have drifted longer across books (\u2191 +4.8%, 7/11) \u2014 market pricing moves against this side.",
          "This creates a conflict: Model \u2192 Hebei Kungfu, Market \u2192 Guangxi Pingguo Haliao, while Hebei Kungfu odds drifted longer (market fade).",
          "Because signals disagree, confidence remains limited."
        ],
        "show": true,
        "title": "OddsGPT Interpretation"
      },
      "lifecycle": {
        "closing_implied_pct": 65.79,
        "closing_odds": 1.52,
        "closing_reason": "",
        "closing_status": "recorded",
        "closing_status_label": "Recorded",
        "clv_pending": true,
        "clv_pp": 0.0,
        "clv_reason": "",
        "clv_status": "pending",
        "context": "match",
        "current_stage": "waiting_for_kickoff",
        "current_stage_detail": "",
        "current_stage_label": "Waiting for kickoff",
        "entry_implied_pct": 65.79,
        "entry_odds": 1.52,
        "match_phase": "upcoming",
        "match_phase_detail": "",
        "match_phase_display": "Upcoming",
        "match_phase_label": "Upcoming",
        "model_validation_label": "Warning",
        "model_validation_status": "warning",
        "stages": [
          {
            "detail": "",
            "id": "forecast_generated",
            "label": "Prediction Generated",
            "status": "done"
          },
          {
            "detail": "",
            "id": "market_detected",
            "label": "Market Compared",
            "status": "active"
          },
          {
            "detail": "",
            "id": "model_validated",
            "label": "Validation Passed",
            "status": "active"
          },
          {
            "detail": "PRE1",
            "id": "closing_recorded",
            "label": "Closing Recorded",
            "status": "done"
          },
          {
            "detail": "",
            "id": "clv_evaluated",
            "label": "CLV Evaluated",
            "status": "pending"
          }
        ]
      },
      "market_move_intelligence": {
        "books_reacting": 7,
        "books_reacting_detail": [
          {
            "bookmaker_id": 7,
            "bookmaker_name": "William Hill",
            "is_sharp": false,
            "move_delta_display": "\u2191 +10.0%",
            "odds_delta_pct": 10.0
          },
          {
            "bookmaker_id": 4,
            "bookmaker_name": "Pinnacle",
            "is_sharp": true,
            "move_delta_display": "\u2191 +6.7%",
            "odds_delta_pct": 6.7
          },
          {
            "bookmaker_id": 8,
            "bookmaker_name": "Bet365",
            "is_sharp": true,
            "move_delta_display": "\u2191 +4.8%",
            "odds_delta_pct": 4.8
          },
          {
            "bookmaker_id": 11,
            "bookmaker_name": "1xBet",
            "is_sharp": false,
            "move_delta_display": "\u2191 +4.4%",
            "odds_delta_pct": 4.4
          },
          {
            "bookmaker_id": 2,
            "bookmaker_name": "Marathonbet",
            "is_sharp": false,
            "move_delta_display": "\u2191 +4.4%",
            "odds_delta_pct": 4.4
          },
          {
            "bookmaker_id": 36,
            "bookmaker_name": "BetVictor",
            "is_sharp": false,
            "move_delta_display": "\u2191 +4.3%",
            "odds_delta_pct": 4.3
          },
          {
            "bookmaker_id": 9,
            "bookmaker_name": "Dafabet",
            "is_sharp": false,
            "move_delta_display": "\u2191 +3.3%",
            "odds_delta_pct": 3.3
          }
        ],
        "books_total": 11,
        "breadth_display": "7/11",
        "clv_label": "+0.00 pp",
        "clv_status": "evaluated",
        "current_odds": 5.5,
        "is_drift": true,
        "move_context": "Highest consensus move",
        "move_display": "\u2191 +4.8%",
        "move_pct_abs": 4.8,
        "move_speed_icon": "\ud83d\udc22",
        "move_speed_label": "Slow drift over 50h 40m",
        "narrative_paragraphs": [
          "Pinnacle led repricing on Hebei Kungfu (4.8%) \u2014 sharp book moved before wider follow-through.",
          "A meaningful move led by sharper sportsbooks, with moderate market confirmation."
        ],
        "narrative_title": "Market Narrative",
        "odds_delta_pct": 4.8,
        "odds_path": {
          "chart_y_labels": [
            "5.89",
            "5.57",
            "5.25"
          ],
          "display": "7.00 \u2192 5.00 \u2192 5.50",
          "move_speed_icon": "\ud83d\udc22",
          "move_speed_label": "Slow drift over 50h 40m",
          "pick_team": "Hebei Kungfu",
          "points": [
            {
              "label_key": "open",
              "value": "7.00"
            },
            {
              "label_key": "extreme",
              "value": "5.00"
            },
            {
              "label_key": "current",
              "value": "5.50"
            }
          ],
          "sparkline_points": [
            5.25,
            5.89,
            5.5
          ],
          "sparkline_polyline": "0.0,18.0 28.0,0.0 56.0,11.0",
          "sparkline_trend": "volatile",
          "sparkline_trend_label": "V-shape swing",
          "summary_boxes": [
            {
              "label_key": "open",
              "value": "5.25"
            },
            {
              "label_key": "low",
              "value": "5.25"
            },
            {
              "label_key": "high",
              "value": "5.89"
            },
            {
              "label_key": "current",
              "value": "5.50"
            }
          ]
        },
        "open_odds": 5.25,
        "page_alert_line": "Broad drift across 7/11 sportsbooks on Hebei Kungfu",
        "phase_label": "Sharp repricing",
        "phase_tip": "Aggressive adjustment \u2014 often sharp-led or high consensus.",
        "pick_team": "Hebei Kungfu",
        "ref_book": "Bet365",
        "seo_title_alert": "",
        "sharp_leader": "Pinnacle",
        "show": true,
        "signal_badge_class": "confirm",
        "signal_icon": "\u26a1",
        "signal_impact": {
          "current_odds": 5.5,
          "is_drift": true,
          "label": "Market Signal",
          "move_display": "\u2191 +4.8%",
          "open_odds": 5.25,
          "summary": "Market moved away from Hebei Kungfu while the model still favours another side.",
          "team": "Hebei Kungfu",
          "tone": "against"
        },
        "signal_key": "sharp_led",
        "signal_label": "Sharp-led move",
        "steam_score": 41,
        "steam_subtitle": "Moderate sharp signal",
        "steam_tier": "B",
        "title": "Market Move Intelligence"
      },
      "market_overview": {
        "breadth_display": "7/11",
        "current_odds": 5.5,
        "move_display": "\u2191 +4.8%",
        "open_odds": 5.25,
        "pick_team": "Hebei Kungfu",
        "steam_score": 41,
        "steam_team_name": "Hebei Kungfu",
        "steam_tier": "B"
      },
      "premium_teaser": {
        "current_divergence_pp": 26.4,
        "divergence_label": "Current divergence",
        "title": "Premium Market Intelligence",
        "unlock_items": [
          "Historical similar matches",
          "Closing odds analysis",
          "CLV tracking",
          "Sharp money signals",
          "Market efficiency rating",
          "Historical model vs market results"
        ],
        "unlock_label": "Unlock"
      },
      "show": true
    },
    "match": {
      "away_expected_goals": null,
      "away_goal_display": null,
      "away_team_display_name": "Hebei Kungfu",
      "away_team_id": 17264,
      "away_team_logo": "/static/teams/17264.webp",
      "away_team_name": "Hebei Kungfu",
      "away_team_public_id": "5sp3hTbP1fw1hM",
      "away_team_slug": "hebei-kungfu",
      "country_code": "CN",
      "country_display_name": "China",
      "country_flag": "/static/images/country/cn.svg",
      "country_id": 32,
      "country_name": "China",
      "fixture_id": 1528706,
      "goals_away": null,
      "goals_home": null,
      "home_expected_goals": null,
      "home_goal_display": null,
      "home_team_country": "China",
      "home_team_display_name": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao",
      "home_team_id": 23268,
      "home_team_logo": "/static/teams/23268.webp",
      "home_team_name": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao",
      "home_team_public_id": "3FnWMUh4EGYruY",
      "home_team_slug": "guangxi-hengchen",
      "league_country": "China",
      "league_country_display": "China",
      "league_display_name": "Liga Satu China",
      "league_id": 170,
      "league_logo": "/static/leagues/170.webp",
      "league_name": "Liga Satu China",
      "league_public_id": "0Z8NZOcuHfzq60",
      "league_season": 2026,
      "match_date": "2026-09-06 11:30:00",
      "public_id": "3ODRHVPx2jaNQG",
      "score_fulltime_away": null,
      "score_fulltime_home": null,
      "score_penalty_away": null,
      "score_penalty_home": null,
      "status_long": "Not Started",
      "status_short": "NS",
      "venue_city": "Nanning",
      "venue_name": "Guangxi Sports Center"
    },
    "match_decision": {
      "confidence": {
        "breakdown": [
          "pred_conf_md_max_1x2_under_50",
          "pred_conf_md_top_two_close",
          "pred_conf_md_line_above_ev"
        ],
        "breakdown_resolved": [
          "Max 1X2 prob under 50% (open contest) (\u22121.0)",
          "Top two outcomes relatively close in probability (\u22120.5)",
          "At least one tracked line above +EV threshold (+0.5)"
        ],
        "score": 6.0
      },
      "markets": {
        "1x2": {
          "1x2_ev_mode": "market_first_p15",
          "away": {
            "alpha": 0.1405,
            "best_odd": 5.89,
            "calibration": {
              "active": false,
              "hook": "CALIBRATE_1X2_P_FINAL"
            },
            "edge": 0.0279,
            "ev": 0.0921,
            "implied_prob": 0.1575,
            "joint_probs": {
              "away": 0.1575,
              "draw": 0.232,
              "home": 0.6105
            },
            "model_prob": 0.3559,
            "p_final": 0.1854
          },
          "draw": {
            "alpha": 0.1806,
            "best_odd": 4.0,
            "calibration": {
              "active": false,
              "hook": "CALIBRATE_1X2_P_FINAL"
            },
            "edge": 0.0117,
            "ev": -0.0253,
            "implied_prob": 0.232,
            "joint_probs": {
              "away": 0.1575,
              "draw": 0.232,
              "home": 0.6105
            },
            "model_prob": 0.2968,
            "p_final": 0.2437
          },
          "ev_available": true,
          "home": {
            "alpha": 0.3631,
            "best_odd": 1.52,
            "calibration": {
              "active": false,
              "hook": "CALIBRATE_1X2_P_FINAL"
            },
            "edge": -0.0956,
            "ev": -0.2173,
            "implied_prob": 0.6105,
            "joint_probs": {
              "away": 0.1575,
              "draw": 0.232,
              "home": 0.6105
            },
            "model_prob": 0.3473,
            "p_final": 0.5149
          }
        },
        "1x2_outlier": {
          "1x2_ev_mode": "legacy_max_odd",
          "away": {
            "best_odd": 5.89,
            "edge": 0.1862,
            "ev": 1.0964,
            "implied_prob": 0.1698,
            "model_prob": 0.3559
          },
          "draw": {
            "best_odd": 4.0,
            "edge": 0.0468,
            "ev": 0.1871,
            "implied_prob": 0.25,
            "model_prob": 0.2968
          },
          "ev_available": true,
          "home": {
            "best_odd": 1.52,
            "edge": -0.3106,
            "ev": -0.4721,
            "implied_prob": 0.6579,
            "model_prob": 0.3473
          }
        },
        "btts": {
          "btts_ev_mode": "unavailable",
          "ev_available": false,
          "market_first": {
            "available": false
          },
          "n_bookmakers": 0,
          "reliability": "low"
        },
        "ou25": {
          "ev_available": false,
          "market_first": {
            "available": false
          },
          "n_bookmakers": 0,
          "ou_ev_mode": "unavailable",
          "reliability": "low"
        }
      },
      "match_regime": {
        "action": "avoid",
        "code": "no_edge",
        "execution_line_key": "pred_regime_exec_no_actionable",
        "insight_line_key": "pred_regime_insight_minor_inefficiency",
        "stake_mult": 0.0,
        "use_split_strip": true
      },
      "match_tier": "no_bet",
      "min_ev": 0.02,
      "total_xg": 2.6,
      "variance_flag": false
    },
    "unified_decision": {
      "actionable_ev_threshold": 0.02,
      "algorithm": {
        "enabled_since": "2026-05-26",
        "game_typing_module": true,
        "version": "2.5.0"
      },
      "balanced_alternative": null,
      "best_consensus_ev": 0.0921,
      "best_outlier_ev": 1.0964,
      "best_tracked_ev": 0.0921,
      "confidence": 5.0,
      "decision_confidence_v1": {
        "breakdown": [
          "pred_conf_v1_primary_line",
          "pred_conf_v1_max_1x2_under_50"
        ],
        "breakdown_resolved": [
          "Primary line identified (+1.0)",
          "Max 1X2 prob under 50% (no dominant 1X2) (\u22121.0)"
        ],
        "breakdown_v2": [
          "Base decision score (v1)",
          "Market steam conflicts with model",
          "Consensus-line +EV",
          "Low xG separation (league-average noise)"
        ],
        "guard_capped": true,
        "score": 3.0,
        "score_before_guard": 5.0,
        "score_v1_legacy": 3.0,
        "score_v2_pre_penalty": 3.0,
        "strength_v2": true
      },
      "decision_strength_v2": {
        "breakdown": [
          "Base decision score (v1)",
          "Market steam conflicts with model",
          "Consensus-line +EV",
          "Low xG separation (league-average noise)"
        ],
        "score": 3.0,
        "score_pre_penalty": 3.0
      },
      "decision_type": "VALUE_ALERT",
      "execution": {
        "1x2_dominant": false,
        "1x2_open_contest": true,
        "grade": "B",
        "stake_factor": 0.5
      },
      "favourite_misaligned_1x2": {
        "active": false,
        "gap": null,
        "side": null
      },
      "final_action": "wait",
      "final_decision": {
        "action": "wait",
        "alignment": {
          "direction_aligned": false,
          "direction_key": "conflict",
          "gap_pp": 26.4,
          "key": "conflict",
          "label": "Disagree",
          "model_strong": false,
          "pricing_aligned": false,
          "pricing_key": "low",
          "probability_gap_pp": 26.4,
          "summary": "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu."
        },
        "alignment_key": "conflict",
        "best_consensus_ev": 0.0921,
        "best_outlier_ev": 0.010964,
        "confidence_band": "Moderate\u2013Low",
        "decision_strength": 3.0,
        "decision_strength_v1": 3.0,
        "decision_strength_v2": 3.0,
        "decision_type": "VALUE_ALERT",
        "execution_confidence": 13,
        "extreme_disagreement": false,
        "final_verdict_audit": {
          "action": "Monitor closing market and validate with CLV.",
          "action_label": "Action",
          "decision": "Wait - No Primary Bet",
          "is_primary": false,
          "snapshot": "The Decision Model estimates Hebei Kungfu at 35.6%, compared with a no-vig market probability of 15.8%.",
          "why": [
            {
              "text": "Decision Model identifies Hebei Kungfu as the value side (35.6%)",
              "tone": "ok"
            },
            {
              "text": "Market pricing conflicts with the model lean",
              "tone": "bad"
            },
            {
              "text": "Model\u2013market disagreement blocks Primary sizing",
              "tone": "bad"
            },
            {
              "text": "Market quality / price reliability is insufficient for Primary",
              "tone": "bad"
            },
            {
              "text": "Model confidence reduced due to calibration uncertainty",
              "tone": "bad"
            }
          ],
          "why_label": "Decision Summary"
        },
        "gap_pp": 19.8,
        "gates_failed": [
          "Reliability below 65"
        ],
        "has_top_pick": true,
        "headline": "Wait - No Primary Bet",
        "hero_mode": "default",
        "icon": "\u23f8",
        "label": "Wait for validation",
        "market_signal": "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu.",
        "model_conflict_detail": null,
        "model_lean": "Hebei Kungfu",
        "no_primary_reasons": {
          "all_triggered": [
            "market_conflict",
            "market_quality",
            "calibration_risk"
          ],
          "calibration_mode": "soft",
          "codes": [
            "market_conflict",
            "market_quality"
          ],
          "label": "Reason",
          "other_factors": [
            {
              "code": "market_quality",
              "detail": "Price reliability is weak (thin coverage, outlier quote, or low book agreement).",
              "name": "Market Quality Risk",
              "short": "Market Quality Risk",
              "tone": "warn"
            }
          ],
          "other_label": "Other factors",
          "primary": {
            "code": "market_conflict",
            "detail": "Model lean and market pricing / drift are not aligned.",
            "name": "Market Conflict",
            "short": "Market Conflict",
            "subtype": "drift_against_model",
            "tone": "warn"
          },
          "secondary": {
            "code": "market_quality",
            "detail": "Price reliability is weak (thin coverage, outlier quote, or low book agreement).",
            "name": "Market Quality Risk",
            "short": "Market Quality Risk",
            "tone": "warn"
          },
          "version": "v1"
        },
        "outlier_detected": false,
        "outlier_excluded_panel": "",
        "primary_allowed": false,
        "primary_block_explain": {
          "entries": [
            {
              "key": "positive_ev",
              "label": "Consensus EV +9.2% meets Primary gate (\u2265+5.0%)",
              "ok": true
            },
            {
              "key": "gate",
              "label": "Reliability below 65",
              "ok": false
            }
          ],
          "lean_ev_threshold_pct": 2.0,
          "primary_ev_threshold_pct": 5.0,
          "subtitle": "Primary needs consensus EV \u2265 +5.0% plus reliability/execution/calibration gates (Decision Strength is explain-only). Lean/tracked gate is +2.0% (selective only \u2014 not default Primary sizing).",
          "title": "Why not Primary?"
        },
        "primary_gate_checklist": "Gate checklist: Consensus EV +9.2% \u2705 (need \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration See checklist \u274c \u2192 Primary blocked. Decision Strength 3.0/10 (explain only, not a Primary gate). If you still act under hard block: example stake 0.10\u20130.20% bankroll (never Primary).",
        "primary_gate_snapshot": "Primary Gate Snapshot: Consensus EV +9.2% (gate \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration: See checklist \u2192 Primary blocked \u00b7 Decision Strength 3.0/10 (display only)",
        "primary_gates": {
          "items": [
            {
              "key": "extreme_gap",
              "label": "Extreme gap",
              "ok": true,
              "value": "no"
            },
            {
              "key": "xg_calibration",
              "label": "xG calibration",
              "ok": true,
              "value": "warning"
            },
            {
              "key": "reliability",
              "label": "Rel",
              "ok": false,
              "value": "49 (\u226565)"
            },
            {
              "key": "execution",
              "label": "Exec",
              "ok": false,
              "value": "13 (\u226565)"
            },
            {
              "key": "alignment",
              "label": "Align",
              "ok": false,
              "value": "conflict"
            },
            {
              "key": "consensus_ev",
              "label": "ConsEV",
              "ok": true,
              "value": "+9.2% (\u2265+5.0%)"
            },
            {
              "key": "top_pick",
              "label": "Pick",
              "ok": true,
              "value": "true"
            },
            {
              "key": "validation",
              "label": "Validation",
              "ok": false,
              "value": "false"
            }
          ],
          "passed": 4,
          "total": 8
        },
        "primary_type": null,
        "reasons": [
          "The market has moved away from Hebei Kungfu, but the model still strongly favours Hebei Kungfu.",
          "Decision strength: 3.0/10",
          "Reliability below 65"
        ],
        "reliability_score": 49,
        "speed_read": "Speed read: Model Signal can look moderate/strong while Decision Strength stays low after calibration \u2014 Strength alone does not block Primary (v2.5+); still check reliability/execution/EV hard gates.",
        "strength_v2_breakdown": [
          "Base decision score (v1)",
          "Market steam conflicts with model",
          "Consensus-line +EV",
          "Low xG separation (league-average noise)"
        ],
        "subline": "Model validation or guard rules block actionable value signals.",
        "thresholds": {
          "extreme_gap_pp": 30.0,
          "lean_min_consensus_ev": 0.02,
          "lean_min_strength": 5.0,
          "min_consensus_ev": 0.05,
          "min_execution": 65,
          "min_reliability": 65,
          "min_strength": 7.0,
          "source": "db",
          "user_id": 2
        },
        "thresholds_source": "db",
        "thresholds_user_id": 2,
        "tier": "wait",
        "validation_ok": false,
        "value_context": {
          "consensus_ev": 0.0921,
          "consensus_ev_display": "+9.2%",
          "consensus_odds": 5.89,
          "disagreement_label": "Strong",
          "disagreement_level": "strong",
          "implied_prob": 0.1575,
          "is_extreme_disagreement": false,
          "model_prob": 0.3559,
          "raw_edge_display": "+19.8 percentage points",
          "raw_edge_pp": 19.8,
          "raw_implied_prob": 0.16977928692699493,
          "raw_signal_ev": 1.0963,
          "raw_signal_ev_display": "+109.6%"
        },
        "version": "v2.5",
        "xg_calibration": {
          "block_value_alert": true,
          "calibration_status": "warning",
          "deviation_pct": -3.0,
          "reasons": [
            "Low xG separation gap=0.02 (noise / no edge)"
          ],
          "recommended_action": "monitor",
          "strength_delta": -2.0,
          "uplift_away": null,
          "uplift_home": null,
          "xg_separation": {
            "band": "flat",
            "block_value_alert": true,
            "separation_score": -20,
            "strength_delta": -2.0,
            "xg_gap": 0.02
          }
        }
      },
      "game_type": {
        "label_zh": "\u5747\u8861\uff08\u5f00\u653e\u8d5b\u679c\uff09",
        "scoring_type": "balanced",
        "signals": {
          "btts_yes_prob": 0.545,
          "draw_prob": 0.2968,
          "max_1x2_prob": 0.3559,
          "over_prob": 0.482,
          "total_xg": 2.6,
          "under_prob": 0.518,
          "xg_diff": 0.02
        },
        "type": "balanced",
        "typing_weights_enabled": true
      },
      "guard_active": true,
      "guard_level": "extreme",
      "guard_message": "Model validation failed \u2014 value signals on 1X2 are not actionable until inputs are verified.",
      "hero_display_pick": null,
      "hero_mode": "default",
      "longshot_picks": [],
      "markets": {
        "1x2": {
          "consensus_odds": 5.89,
          "decision": "guard_blocked",
          "decision_before_guard": "value_bet",
          "edge": 0.0279,
          "ev": 0.0921,
          "guard_blocked": true,
          "implied_prob": 0.1575,
          "max_ev_side": "away",
          "model_prob": 0.3559,
          "side": "away",
          "side_label": "Hebei Kungfu"
        },
        "btts": {
          "decision": "lean",
          "decision_layer": {
            "available": false
          },
          "edge": null,
          "ev": null,
          "implied_prob": null,
          "model_prob": 0.545,
          "side": "yes",
          "value_side": "yes"
        },
        "ou_2_5": {
          "decision": "no_bet",
          "decision_layer": {
            "available": false
          },
          "edge": null,
          "ev": null,
          "implied_prob": null,
          "model_prob": 0.518,
          "side": "under",
          "value_side": "under"
        }
      },
      "match_id": 1528706,
      "match_regime": {
        "action": "optional",
        "actionable": true,
        "clear_edge": false,
        "code": "thin_edge",
        "execution_line_key": null,
        "insight_line_key": null,
        "max_valid_ev": 0.0921,
        "min_ev": 0.02,
        "stake_mult": 0.25,
        "use_split_strip": false
      },
      "match_tier": "value_game",
      "no_clear_primary": false,
      "probabilities": {
        "away": 0.3559,
        "draw": 0.2968,
        "home": 0.3473
      },
      "reason_codes": [
        "model_summary"
      ],
      "secondary_pick": null,
      "secondary_picks": [],
      "show_betting_primary_label": false,
      "suppressed_primary": null,
      "teams": {
        "away": "Hebei Kungfu",
        "home": "Guangxi Pingguo Haliao"
      },
      "top_pick": {
        "composite_score": 0.036056,
        "decision": "value_bet",
        "ev": 0.0921,
        "implied_prob": 0.1575,
        "market": "1x2",
        "model_prob": 0.3559,
        "not_dominant": true,
        "primary_strength": "weak",
        "risk_band": "speculative",
        "risk_tier": "primary",
        "side": "away",
        "side_label": "Hebei Kungfu",
        "slot": "primary",
        "speculative_primary": true
      },
      "valid_markets_count": 1,
      "value_context_1x2": {
        "consensus_ev": 0.0921,
        "consensus_ev_display": "+9.2%",
        "consensus_odds": 5.89,
        "disagreement_label": "Strong",
        "disagreement_level": "strong",
        "implied_prob": 0.1575,
        "is_extreme_disagreement": false,
        "model_prob": 0.3559,
        "raw_edge_display": "+19.8 percentage points",
        "raw_edge_pp": 19.8,
        "raw_implied_prob": 0.16977928692699493,
        "raw_signal_ev": 1.0963,
        "raw_signal_ev_display": "+109.6%"
      }
    }
  },
  "fixture_id": 1528706,
  "generated_at_utc": "2026-09-06T11:29:13.864484+00:00",
  "lang_id": "en"
}

Dapatkan Ramalan Premium untuk Guangxi Pingguo Haliao & Hebei Kungfu!

Buka analisis mendalam, tip pertaruhan eksklusif, dan ramalan perlawanan dengan perkhidmatan langganan premium kami.

Langgan Sekarang
Kembali ke Statistik
Liga Satu China Liga Satu China — Kedudukan
# PASUKAN P M S K Mata
1 Guangzhou E-Power 24 16 6 2 54
2 Guangxi Pingguo Haliao 24 13 6 5 45
3 Shenzhen Juniors 24 12 8 4 44
4 Nantong Zhiyun 23 10 9 4 39
5 Yanbian Longding 24 9 8 7 35
6 Shaanxi Union 23 9 6 8 33
7 Hebei Kungfu 24 8 7 9 31
8 Wuxi Wugou 23 8 5 10 29
9 Changchun Yatai 23 10 3 10 29
10 Ningbo Professional 23 9 5 9 29
11 Dalian Huayi 23 7 8 8 29
12 Suzhou Dongwu 24 7 8 9 26
13 Heilongjiang Lava Spring 24 4 11 9 23
14 Nanjing City 24 5 6 13 21
15 Meizhou Kejia 24 7 3 14 15
16 Dongguan United 24 2 7 15 13
# PASUKAN P J B +/- Mata
1 Guangzhou E-Power 24 48 20 +28 54
2 Guangxi Pingguo Haliao 24 40 26 +14 45
3 Shenzhen Juniors 24 39 25 +14 44
4 Changchun Yatai 23 37 38 -1 29
5 Shaanxi Union 23 35 26 +9 33
6 Wuxi Wugou 23 35 29 +6 29
7 Heilongjiang Lava Spring 24 35 46 -11 23
8 Yanbian Longding 24 33 27 +6 35
9 Nantong Zhiyun 23 31 20 +11 39
10 Dalian Huayi 23 30 33 -3 29
11 Suzhou Dongwu 24 28 33 -5 26
12 Ningbo Professional 23 27 29 -2 29
13 Meizhou Kejia 24 25 50 -25 15
14 Dongguan United 24 24 49 -25 13
15 Hebei Kungfu 24 22 25 -3 31
16 Nanjing City 24 20 33 -13 21