Pasaran yang dijejaki vs hasil sepenuh masa
Setiap baris membandingkan model pra-perlawanan lean dengan keputusan sepenuh masa.
- Pasaran Ramalan Hasilnya Hasil
- Over / Under 2.5 Under 2.5 Over 2.5 (4 matlamat) ✖ tak betul
- Kedua-dua Pasukan Menjaringkan Gol BTTS Tidak Ya ✖ tak betul
- 1X2 Atlético-MG Lukis ✖ tak betul
- Cerapan skor tepat 1-1, 0-1, 1-0, 0-0, 1-2 2-2 ✖ tak betul
Validation Report
Immutable SnapshotModel Performance
This prediction contributes to:
- Primary Bets ROI (180d): -100.0%
Taklimat AI untuk perlawanan ini belum tersedia. Selepas naik taraf pelayan, jalankan semula “Batch generate odds” untuk menjana ringkasan.
View technical JSON
{
"bundle_version": 1,
"content_hash": "71f886543e96e398d48c37fec6e55168a77ee915505b1b9275acb5d1d470d8bb",
"decision_algo_version": "2.5.0",
"facts": {
"ai_fp": {
"away_predicted_xg": 1.23,
"away_win_prob": 0.3531,
"away_win_prob_posterior": null,
"bayes_applied": 0,
"btts_no_prob": 0.489,
"btts_yes_prob": 0.511,
"dc_rho": -0.13,
"draw_prob": 0.3083,
"draw_prob_posterior": null,
"fair_odds_away": 2.83,
"fair_odds_away_posterior": null,
"fair_odds_draw": 3.24,
"fair_odds_draw_posterior": null,
"fair_odds_home": 2.95,
"fair_odds_home_posterior": null,
"home_predicted_xg": 1.2,
"home_win_prob": 0.3386,
"home_win_prob_posterior": null,
"over_25_prob": 0.438,
"prediction_confidence": "low",
"under_25_prob": 0.562
},
"api_prediction": {
"advice": "Double chance : draw or Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"main_pick_display": "No Strong Winner Bet",
"percent_away": "45%",
"percent_draw": "45%",
"percent_home": "10%",
"winner_name": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG"
},
"away_xg": 1.23,
"betting_insight": {
"bet_label": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"confidence": null,
"main_pick_meta": {
"confidence": "low",
"display_text": "No Strong Winner Bet",
"edge": 0.0738,
"edge_gap": 0.0144,
"market": "1X2",
"market_prob": 0.2792,
"model_prob": 0.353,
"pick_type": "no_strong",
"probabilities": {
"away": 35.3,
"draw": 30.8,
"home": 33.9
},
"reason": "No clear edge in 1X2 market",
"selection": null,
"selection_name": null
},
"market_comparison": [
{
"affi_link": "https://banners.dfbanners.com/redirect.aspx?pid=79572\u0026bid=19634\u0026redirectURL=http://www.dafabet.com/",
"bookmaker_name": "Dafabet",
"odd": 3.65
},
{
"affi_link": "",
"bookmaker_name": "Pinnacle",
"odd": 3.55
},
{
"affi_link": "https://reffpa.com/L?tag=d_4682699m_1260c_\u0026site=4682699\u0026ad=1260",
"bookmaker_name": "1xBet",
"odd": 3.53
},
{
"affi_link": "",
"bookmaker_name": "Marathonbet",
"odd": 3.42
},
{
"affi_link": "",
"bookmaker_name": "Betfair",
"odd": 3.4
},
{
"affi_link": "",
"bookmaker_name": "Bet365",
"odd": 3.3
},
{
"affi_link": "",
"bookmaker_name": "Betano",
"odd": 3.3
},
{
"affi_link": "",
"bookmaker_name": "BetVictor",
"odd": 3.3
}
],
"risk_color": null,
"risk_key": null,
"stacked_market": null,
"value_bet": {
"best_odds": 3.65,
"bookmaker_affi": "https://banners.dfbanners.com/redirect.aspx?pid=79572\u0026bid=19634\u0026redirectURL=http://www.dafabet.com/",
"bookmaker_id": 9,
"bookmaker_name": "Dafabet",
"display_market": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG Win",
"is_value": true,
"label": "Away",
"market_fair_odds": 3.58,
"market_odds": 3.36,
"model_odds": 2.83,
"overround": 6.6,
"prob_edge": 7.9,
"value_pct": 29.0,
"value_rating": "strong_value"
}
},
"betting_markets": {
"btts": {
"away_clean_sheet": 6,
"away_failed_to_score": 9,
"away_played": 27,
"away_score_rate": 70.8,
"home_clean_sheet": 8,
"home_failed_to_score": 6,
"home_played": 28,
"home_score_rate": 69.9,
"no_prob": 48.9,
"pick": "No",
"pick_prob": 51.1,
"source": "xG_dc",
"strong_pick": true,
"yes_prob": 51.1
},
"correct_score": {
"away_expected": 1.23,
"home_expected": 1.2,
"scores": [
{
"away": 1,
"home": 1,
"label": "1-1",
"prob": 13.0
},
{
"away": 1,
"home": 0,
"label": "0-1",
"prob": 10.8
},
{
"away": 0,
"home": 1,
"label": "1-0",
"prob": 10.6
},
{
"away": 0,
"home": 0,
"label": "0-0",
"prob": 8.8
},
{
"away": 2,
"home": 1,
"label": "1-2",
"prob": 8.0
}
],
"source": "xG"
},
"double_chance": {
"options": [
{
"key": "1X",
"label": "Athletico Paranaense or Draw",
"prob": 64.7
},
{
"key": "12",
"label": "Athletico Paranaense or Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"prob": 69.2
},
{
"key": "X2",
"label": "Draw or Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"prob": 66.1
}
],
"pick_key": "12",
"pick_label": "Athletico Paranaense or Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"pick_prob": 69.2
},
"match_winner": {
"away_pct": 35.3,
"draw_pct": 30.8,
"home_pct": 33.9,
"lean_key": "away",
"lean_label": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG"
},
"over_under": {
"api_hint": null,
"avg_total": 2.43,
"away_avg_scored": 1.3,
"confidence": "medium",
"home_avg_scored": 1.5,
"over_prob": 43.8,
"pick": "Under 2.5",
"pick_prob": 56.2,
"source": "xG_dc",
"strong_pick": true,
"total_expected": 2.43,
"under_prob": 56.2
},
"prob_source": "poisson",
"value_bet_enhanced": {
"bookmaker_id": 9,
"bookmaker_name": "Dafabet",
"edge": 29.0,
"implied_prob": 27.4,
"is_value": true,
"label": "Away",
"market": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG Win",
"model_prob": 35.3,
"odds": 3.65
}
},
"closing_line_bundle": {
"has_data": false
},
"correct_score_insight": {
"best_value": null,
"lean_card": {
"diff_pp": -2.4,
"ev": -0.155,
"has_edge": false,
"label": "1-1",
"market_odds": 6.5,
"market_prob": 0.1538,
"market_prob_pct": 15.4,
"model_prob": 0.13,
"model_prob_pct": 13.0,
"n_bookmakers": 8,
"status_key": "no_value"
},
"most_likely": {
"label": "1-1",
"prob": 13.0
},
"top5": [
{
"label": "1-1",
"prob": 13.0
},
{
"label": "0-1",
"prob": 10.8
},
{
"label": "1-0",
"prob": 10.6
},
{
"label": "0-0",
"prob": 8.8
},
{
"label": "1-2",
"prob": 8.0
}
]
},
"home_xg": 1.2,
"homepage_pick": null,
"market_cards": [
{
"decision": "small_edge",
"decision_layer": {
"alpha": 0.3835,
"available": true,
"consensus_odds": 1.79,
"edge": 0.0132,
"edge_pp": 1.3,
"market_prob": 0.5277,
"mode": "market_first_ou",
"model_prob": 0.562,
"n_bookmakers": 8,
"over": {
"alpha": 0.3486,
"best_odd": 2.0,
"edge": -0.012,
"ev": -0.0793,
"implied_prob": 0.4723,
"model_prob": 0.438,
"p_final": 0.4603
},
"p_final": 0.5409,
"prediction_confidence": "low",
"raw_edge_pp": 3.4,
"raw_signal_ev": 0.006,
"risk_adj_ev": -0.0319,
"under": {
"alpha": 0.3835,
"best_odd": 1.79,
"edge": 0.0132,
"ev": -0.0319,
"implied_prob": 0.5277,
"model_prob": 0.562,
"p_final": 0.5409
},
"value_side": "under"
},
"ev_available": true,
"ev_over": -0.089,
"ev_over_display": {
"capped": false,
"raw_pct": -8.9,
"text": "-8.9%"
},
"ev_under": 0.0285,
"ev_under_display": {
"capped": false,
"raw_pct": 2.9,
"text": "+2.9%"
},
"featured": true,
"id": "ou_2_5",
"max_ev": 0.0285,
"n_bookmakers": 8,
"over_prob": 43.8,
"sort_key": 5222.8,
"tier": "lean",
"under_prob": 56.2,
"value_side": "under"
},
{
"decision": "small_edge",
"decision_layer": {
"alpha": 0.3438,
"available": true,
"consensus_odds": 1.945,
"edge": 0.0041,
"edge_pp": 0.4,
"market_prob": 0.4772,
"mode": "market_first_btts",
"model_prob": 0.489,
"n_bookmakers": 7,
"no": {
"alpha": 0.3438,
"best_odd": 1.945,
"edge": 0.0041,
"ev": -0.064,
"implied_prob": 0.4772,
"model_prob": 0.489,
"p_final": 0.4812
},
"p_final": 0.4812,
"prediction_confidence": "low",
"raw_edge_pp": 1.2,
"raw_signal_ev": -0.0489,
"risk_adj_ev": -0.064,
"value_side": "no",
"yes": {
"alpha": 0.3782,
"best_odd": 1.775,
"edge": -0.0045,
"ev": -0.0799,
"implied_prob": 0.5228,
"model_prob": 0.511,
"p_final": 0.5184
}
},
"ev_available": true,
"ev_no": 0.0269,
"ev_no_display": {
"capped": false,
"raw_pct": 2.7,
"text": "+2.7%"
},
"ev_yes": -0.0802,
"ev_yes_display": {
"capped": false,
"raw_pct": -8.0,
"text": "-8.0%"
},
"featured": false,
"id": "btts",
"max_ev": 0.0269,
"n_bookmakers": 7,
"no_prob": 48.9,
"sort_key": 5221.52,
"tier": "lean",
"value_side": "no",
"yes_prob": 51.1
},
{
"authority_action": "no_bet",
"authority_note": "Some consensus value may remain, but Primary hard gates are not fully cleared.",
"consensus_odds": 3.35,
"decision": "small_edge",
"disagreement_label": "Moderate",
"disagreement_level": "moderate",
"ev": 0.0014,
"ev_available": true,
"ev_display": {
"capped": false,
"raw_pct": 0.1,
"text": "+0.1%"
},
"featured": false,
"id": "1x2",
"implied_prob": 0.2792,
"is_extreme_disagreement": false,
"max_ev": 0.0014,
"max_ev_display": {
"capped": false,
"raw_pct": 0.1,
"text": "+0.1%"
},
"model_prob": 0.353,
"raw_edge_display": "+7.4 percentage points",
"raw_edge_pp": 7.4,
"raw_signal_ev": 0.1825,
"raw_signal_ev_display": "+18.2%",
"show_primary_label": false,
"side_label": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"sort_key": 5201.12,
"tier": "lean"
},
{
"featured": false,
"id": "correct_score",
"sort_key": 819.0,
"tier": "risk",
"top_label": "1-1",
"top_prob": 13.0
}
],
"market_intelligence": {
"betting_signal": {
"alert_breadth": "9/10",
"alert_breadth_note": "9/10 sportsbooks confirmed",
"alert_move": "\u2193 -8.3%",
"alert_team": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"alert_title": "Sharp Money Alert",
"divergence_pp": 0.0,
"has_alert": true,
"hero_edge_pp": null,
"hero_label": "",
"market_prob_pct": null,
"market_team": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"model_prob_pct": 35.3,
"model_team": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"show": true,
"status_icon": "\u2713",
"status_key": "aligned",
"status_label": "Reliable prediction",
"status_line": "Direction aligned; check pricing gap separately",
"steam_score": 61,
"steam_subtitle": "Strong sharp signal",
"steam_tier": "A",
"title": "Betting Signal"
},
"decision_chain": {
"academy_links": [
{
"key": "steam",
"read_min": 4,
"title": "What Is a Steam Move?",
"url": "/academy/betting-market/what-is-a-steam-move/en"
},
{
"key": "clv_pending",
"read_min": 3,
"title": "Why CLV Matters More Than Win Rate",
"url": "/academy/clv/why-clv-matters-more-than-win-rate/en"
}
],
"alignment": {
"direction_aligned": true,
"direction_key": "agree",
"gap_pp": 7.4,
"key": "agree",
"label": "Agree",
"model_strong": false,
"pricing_aligned": true,
"pricing_key": "moderate",
"probability_gap_pp": 7.4,
"summary": "Model and market currently agree on the stronger side (Atl\u00e9tico-MG)."
},
"authority": {
"action": "no_bet",
"alignment": {
"direction_aligned": true,
"direction_key": "agree",
"gap_pp": 7.4,
"key": "agree",
"label": "Agree",
"model_strong": false,
"pricing_aligned": true,
"pricing_key": "moderate",
"probability_gap_pp": 7.4,
"summary": "Model and market currently agree on the stronger side (Atl\u00e9tico-MG)."
},
"alignment_key": "agree",
"best_consensus_ev": 0.0285,
"best_outlier_ev": 0.2885,
"confidence_band": "Moderate\u2013Low",
"decision_strength": 3.5,
"decision_strength_v1": 4.0,
"decision_strength_v2": 5.5,
"decision_type": "NO_SIGNAL",
"execution_confidence": 72,
"extreme_disagreement": false,
"final_verdict_audit": {
"action": "Monitor closing market and validate with CLV.",
"action_label": "Action",
"decision": "No Primary Bet",
"is_primary": false,
"snapshot": "The Decision Model estimates Atl\u00e9tico-MG at 35.3%, compared with a no-vig market probability of 27.9%.",
"why": [
{
"text": "Decision Model identifies Atl\u00e9tico-MG as the value side (35.3%)",
"tone": "ok"
},
{
"text": "Market broadly agrees with the direction",
"tone": "ok"
},
{
"text": "Market quality / price reliability is insufficient for Primary",
"tone": "bad"
},
{
"text": "Edge does not clear Primary threshold",
"tone": "bad"
},
{
"text": "Model confidence reduced due to calibration uncertainty",
"tone": "bad"
}
],
"why_label": "Decision Summary"
},
"gap_pp": 7.4,
"gates_failed": [
"No consensus-line +EV at Primary threshold"
],
"has_top_pick": false,
"headline": "No Primary Bet",
"hero_mode": "default",
"icon": "\u25cb",
"label": "No Primary Bet",
"market_signal": "Market aligns with model lean",
"model_conflict_detail": null,
"model_lean": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"no_primary_reasons": {
"all_triggered": [
"market_quality",
"edge_low",
"calibration_risk"
],
"calibration_mode": "soft",
"codes": [
"market_quality",
"edge_low"
],
"label": "Reason",
"other_factors": [
{
"code": "edge_low",
"detail": "The estimated edge does not meet the Primary threshold.",
"name": "Edge Below Threshold",
"short": "Edge Below Threshold",
"tone": "neutral"
}
],
"other_label": "Other factors",
"primary": {
"code": "market_quality",
"detail": "Price reliability is weak (thin coverage, outlier quote, or low book agreement).",
"name": "Market Quality Risk",
"short": "Market Quality Risk",
"tone": "warn"
},
"secondary": {
"code": "edge_low",
"detail": "The estimated edge does not meet the Primary threshold.",
"name": "Edge Below Threshold",
"short": "Edge Below Threshold",
"tone": "neutral"
},
"version": "v1"
},
"outlier_detected": true,
"outlier_excluded_panel": "Excluded top quotes (audit row \u2014 never Primary): #1 \u00b7 market 1X2 \u00b7 side Atl\u00e9tico-MG \u00b7 decimal odds ~3.80 (derived from model% \u00d7 (1+EV)) \u00b7 EV +29% \u00b7 book: not captured on live render (see odds history / admin snapshot) \u00b7 captured: \u2014 \u00b7 audit_ref: fixture=1492390 \u00b7 snapshot=live-render \u00b7 odds\u22483.80 \u00b7 reason=thin|single-book|\u0394EV\u22653.0%EV \u00b7 book=admin-only \u00b7 trigger: outlier EV \u2212 consensus EV \u2265 +3.0% EV (not probability pp) AND thin/single-book style \u00b7 consensus used +2.9% EV. Excluded quotes cannot clear Primary.",
"primary_allowed": false,
"primary_block_explain": {
"entries": [
{
"key": "weak_ev",
"label": "Consensus EV +2.9% \u003c Primary gate +5.0% (Lean gate +2.0% is separate \u2014 not Primary)",
"ok": false
},
{
"key": "gate",
"label": "No consensus-line +EV at Primary threshold",
"ok": false
}
],
"lean_ev_threshold_pct": 2.0,
"primary_ev_threshold_pct": 5.0,
"subtitle": "Primary needs consensus EV \u2265 +5.0% plus reliability/execution/calibration gates (Decision Strength is explain-only). Lean/tracked gate is +2.0% (selective only \u2014 not default Primary sizing).",
"title": "Why not Primary?"
},
"primary_gate_checklist": "Gate checklist: Consensus EV +2.9% \u274c (need \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration See checklist \u274c \u2192 Primary blocked. Decision Strength 3.5/10 (explain only, not a Primary gate). If you still act under hard block: example stake 0.10\u20130.20% bankroll (never Primary).",
"primary_gate_snapshot": "Primary Gate Snapshot: Consensus EV +2.9% (gate \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration: See checklist \u2192 Primary blocked \u00b7 Decision Strength 3.5/10 (display only)",
"primary_gates": {
"items": [
{
"key": "extreme_gap",
"label": "Extreme gap",
"ok": true,
"value": "no"
},
{
"key": "xg_calibration",
"label": "xG calibration",
"ok": true,
"value": "warning"
},
{
"key": "reliability",
"label": "Rel",
"ok": true,
"value": "69 (\u226565)"
},
{
"key": "execution",
"label": "Exec",
"ok": true,
"value": "72 (\u226565)"
},
{
"key": "alignment",
"label": "Align",
"ok": true,
"value": "agree"
},
{
"key": "consensus_ev",
"label": "ConsEV",
"ok": false,
"value": "+2.9% (\u2265+5.0%)"
},
{
"key": "top_pick",
"label": "Pick",
"ok": false,
"value": "false"
},
{
"key": "validation",
"label": "Validation",
"ok": true,
"value": "true"
}
],
"passed": 6,
"total": 8
},
"primary_type": null,
"reasons": [
"Model and market currently agree on the stronger side (Atl\u00e9tico-MG).",
"Decision strength: 3.5/10",
"No consensus-line +EV at Primary threshold",
"Outlier price +29% EV detected \u2014 not used for Primary (consensus only)."
],
"reliability_score": 69,
"speed_read": "Speed read: Model Signal can look moderate/strong while Decision Strength stays low after calibration \u2014 Strength alone does not block Primary (v2.5+); still check reliability/execution/EV hard gates.",
"strength_v2_breakdown": [
"Base decision score (v1)",
"Reliability supports action",
"Market aligns with model",
"Thin consensus value",
"Low xG separation (league-average noise)"
],
"subline": "Some consensus value may remain, but Primary hard gates are not fully cleared.",
"thresholds": {
"extreme_gap_pp": 30.0,
"lean_min_consensus_ev": 0.02,
"lean_min_strength": 5.0,
"min_consensus_ev": 0.05,
"min_execution": 65,
"min_reliability": 65,
"min_strength": 7.0,
"source": "db",
"user_id": 2
},
"thresholds_source": "db",
"thresholds_user_id": 2,
"tier": "observe",
"validation_ok": true,
"value_context": {
"consensus_ev": 0.0014,
"consensus_ev_display": "+0.1%",
"consensus_odds": 3.35,
"disagreement_label": "Moderate",
"disagreement_level": "moderate",
"implied_prob": 0.2792,
"is_extreme_disagreement": false,
"model_prob": 0.353,
"raw_edge_display": "+7.4 percentage points",
"raw_edge_pp": 7.4,
"raw_implied_prob": 0.29850746268656714,
"raw_signal_ev": 0.1825,
"raw_signal_ev_display": "+18.2%"
},
"version": "v2.5",
"xg_calibration": {
"block_value_alert": true,
"calibration_status": "warning",
"deviation_pct": -8.9,
"reasons": [
"Low xG separation gap=0.03 (noise / no edge)"
],
"recommended_action": "monitor",
"strength_delta": -2.0,
"uplift_away": null,
"uplift_home": null,
"xg_separation": {
"band": "flat",
"block_value_alert": true,
"separation_score": -20,
"strength_delta": -2.0,
"xg_gap": 0.03
}
}
},
"bet_status": "no_bet",
"books_breadth_display": "9/10",
"breadth_ratio": 0.9,
"evidence": {
"score": 78,
"signals": [
{
"icon": "\u25cb",
"key": "statistical_edge",
"label": "No strong statistical edge",
"status": "neutral"
},
{
"icon": "!",
"key": "market_agreement",
"label": "Direction agrees; pricing still diverges",
"status": "caution"
},
{
"icon": "\u2713",
"key": "steam",
"label": "Sharp steam supports model side (direction only \u2014 not pricing convergence)",
"status": "pass"
},
{
"icon": "!",
"key": "validation",
"label": "Validation pending",
"status": "caution"
}
],
"stars": 4,
"tier": "high",
"tier_label": "High"
},
"forecast_reliability": {
"breakdown": [
{
"key": "validation",
"label": "Validation: Pending",
"tone": "ok"
},
{
"key": "steam",
"label": "Steam aligns with model",
"tone": "ok"
}
],
"parts": {
"alignment": 25.0,
"data_quality": 12.0,
"market_coverage": 9.0,
"steam_coherence": 10.0,
"validation": 8.0
},
"score": 69,
"stars": 3,
"tier": "moderate",
"tier_label": "Moderate"
},
"lean_gap_pp": 0.0,
"market_agreement": "unknown",
"max_gap_pp": 0.0,
"model_calibration": {
"away_xg": 1.23,
"calibration_status": "ok",
"deviation_pct": -9.0,
"elevated": false,
"home_xg": 1.2,
"impact_note": "",
"league_avg_xg": 1.35,
"peak_xg": 1.23,
"status_label": "Within typical league range",
"summary": "Home xG 1.20 \u00b7 Away xG 1.23 \u00b7 League avg 1.35 \u00b7 Peak deviation -9%",
"title": "Model Calibration Check"
},
"move_is_drift": false,
"mv_status": "pending",
"odds_delta_pct": -8.3,
"steam_conflicts": false,
"steam_move_display": "\u2193 -8.3%",
"steam_team": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"suppress_execution": false,
"value_split": {
"execution_confidence": {
"label": "Betting Confidence",
"score": 72,
"tier": "high",
"tier_label": "High"
},
"market_compatibility": {
"label": "Pricing proximity (inverse gap)",
"note": "This score falls as the probability gap (pp) rises \u2014 it is NOT a bet green light. Direction may still agree (see Alignment above). Formula: proximity = max(0, 100 \u2212 5\u00d7pp). Example: 16 pp \u2192 20/100 (diverged).",
"score": 63,
"tier": "moderate",
"tier_label": "Moderate"
},
"model_edge_strength": {
"label": "Model Signal Strength",
"score": 35,
"tier": "low",
"tier_label": "Low"
},
"model_value": {
"label": "Pricing proximity (inverse gap)",
"note": "This score falls as the probability gap (pp) rises \u2014 it is NOT a bet green light. Direction may still agree (see Alignment above). Formula: proximity = max(0, 100 \u2212 5\u00d7pp). Example: 16 pp \u2192 20/100 (diverged).",
"score": 63,
"tier": "moderate",
"tier_label": "Moderate"
},
"recommendation": {
"action": "no_bet",
"label": "No Primary Bet"
}
},
"verdict": {
"agree_note": "Some consensus value may remain, but Primary hard gates are not fully cleared.",
"alignment": {
"direction_aligned": true,
"direction_key": "agree",
"gap_pp": 7.4,
"key": "agree",
"label": "Agree",
"model_strong": false,
"pricing_aligned": true,
"pricing_key": "moderate",
"probability_gap_pp": 7.4,
"summary": "Model and market currently agree on the stronger side (Atl\u00e9tico-MG)."
},
"authority": {
"action": "no_bet",
"alignment": {
"direction_aligned": true,
"direction_key": "agree",
"gap_pp": 7.4,
"key": "agree",
"label": "Agree",
"model_strong": false,
"pricing_aligned": true,
"pricing_key": "moderate",
"probability_gap_pp": 7.4,
"summary": "Model and market currently agree on the stronger side (Atl\u00e9tico-MG)."
},
"alignment_key": "agree",
"best_consensus_ev": 0.0285,
"best_outlier_ev": 0.2885,
"confidence_band": "Moderate\u2013Low",
"decision_strength": 3.5,
"decision_strength_v1": 4.0,
"decision_strength_v2": 5.5,
"decision_type": "NO_SIGNAL",
"execution_confidence": 72,
"extreme_disagreement": false,
"final_verdict_audit": {
"action": "Monitor closing market and validate with CLV.",
"action_label": "Action",
"decision": "No Primary Bet",
"is_primary": false,
"snapshot": "The Decision Model estimates Atl\u00e9tico-MG at 35.3%, compared with a no-vig market probability of 27.9%.",
"why": [
{
"text": "Decision Model identifies Atl\u00e9tico-MG as the value side (35.3%)",
"tone": "ok"
},
{
"text": "Market broadly agrees with the direction",
"tone": "ok"
},
{
"text": "Market quality / price reliability is insufficient for Primary",
"tone": "bad"
},
{
"text": "Edge does not clear Primary threshold",
"tone": "bad"
},
{
"text": "Model confidence reduced due to calibration uncertainty",
"tone": "bad"
}
],
"why_label": "Decision Summary"
},
"gap_pp": 7.4,
"gates_failed": [
"No consensus-line +EV at Primary threshold"
],
"has_top_pick": false,
"headline": "No Primary Bet",
"hero_mode": "default",
"icon": "\u25cb",
"label": "No Primary Bet",
"market_signal": "Market aligns with model lean",
"model_conflict_detail": null,
"model_lean": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"no_primary_reasons": {
"all_triggered": [
"market_quality",
"edge_low",
"calibration_risk"
],
"calibration_mode": "soft",
"codes": [
"market_quality",
"edge_low"
],
"label": "Reason",
"other_factors": [
{
"code": "edge_low",
"detail": "The estimated edge does not meet the Primary threshold.",
"name": "Edge Below Threshold",
"short": "Edge Below Threshold",
"tone": "neutral"
}
],
"other_label": "Other factors",
"primary": {
"code": "market_quality",
"detail": "Price reliability is weak (thin coverage, outlier quote, or low book agreement).",
"name": "Market Quality Risk",
"short": "Market Quality Risk",
"tone": "warn"
},
"secondary": {
"code": "edge_low",
"detail": "The estimated edge does not meet the Primary threshold.",
"name": "Edge Below Threshold",
"short": "Edge Below Threshold",
"tone": "neutral"
},
"version": "v1"
},
"outlier_detected": true,
"outlier_excluded_panel": "Excluded top quotes (audit row \u2014 never Primary): #1 \u00b7 market 1X2 \u00b7 side Atl\u00e9tico-MG \u00b7 decimal odds ~3.80 (derived from model% \u00d7 (1+EV)) \u00b7 EV +29% \u00b7 book: not captured on live render (see odds history / admin snapshot) \u00b7 captured: \u2014 \u00b7 audit_ref: fixture=1492390 \u00b7 snapshot=live-render \u00b7 odds\u22483.80 \u00b7 reason=thin|single-book|\u0394EV\u22653.0%EV \u00b7 book=admin-only \u00b7 trigger: outlier EV \u2212 consensus EV \u2265 +3.0% EV (not probability pp) AND thin/single-book style \u00b7 consensus used +2.9% EV. Excluded quotes cannot clear Primary.",
"primary_allowed": false,
"primary_block_explain": {
"entries": [
{
"key": "weak_ev",
"label": "Consensus EV +2.9% \u003c Primary gate +5.0% (Lean gate +2.0% is separate \u2014 not Primary)",
"ok": false
},
{
"key": "gate",
"label": "No consensus-line +EV at Primary threshold",
"ok": false
}
],
"lean_ev_threshold_pct": 2.0,
"primary_ev_threshold_pct": 5.0,
"subtitle": "Primary needs consensus EV \u2265 +5.0% plus reliability/execution/calibration gates (Decision Strength is explain-only). Lean/tracked gate is +2.0% (selective only \u2014 not default Primary sizing).",
"title": "Why not Primary?"
},
"primary_gate_checklist": "Gate checklist: Consensus EV +2.9% \u274c (need \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration See checklist \u274c \u2192 Primary blocked. Decision Strength 3.5/10 (explain only, not a Primary gate). If you still act under hard block: example stake 0.10\u20130.20% bankroll (never Primary).",
"primary_gate_snapshot": "Primary Gate Snapshot: Consensus EV +2.9% (gate \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration: See checklist \u2192 Primary blocked \u00b7 Decision Strength 3.5/10 (display only)",
"primary_gates": {
"items": [
{
"key": "extreme_gap",
"label": "Extreme gap",
"ok": true,
"value": "no"
},
{
"key": "xg_calibration",
"label": "xG calibration",
"ok": true,
"value": "warning"
},
{
"key": "reliability",
"label": "Rel",
"ok": true,
"value": "69 (\u226565)"
},
{
"key": "execution",
"label": "Exec",
"ok": true,
"value": "72 (\u226565)"
},
{
"key": "alignment",
"label": "Align",
"ok": true,
"value": "agree"
},
{
"key": "consensus_ev",
"label": "ConsEV",
"ok": false,
"value": "+2.9% (\u2265+5.0%)"
},
{
"key": "top_pick",
"label": "Pick",
"ok": false,
"value": "false"
},
{
"key": "validation",
"label": "Validation",
"ok": true,
"value": "true"
}
],
"passed": 6,
"total": 8
},
"primary_type": null,
"reasons": [
"Model and market currently agree on the stronger side (Atl\u00e9tico-MG).",
"Decision strength: 3.5/10",
"No consensus-line +EV at Primary threshold",
"Outlier price +29% EV detected \u2014 not used for Primary (consensus only)."
],
"reliability_score": 69,
"speed_read": "Speed read: Model Signal can look moderate/strong while Decision Strength stays low after calibration \u2014 Strength alone does not block Primary (v2.5+); still check reliability/execution/EV hard gates.",
"strength_v2_breakdown": [
"Base decision score (v1)",
"Reliability supports action",
"Market aligns with model",
"Thin consensus value",
"Low xG separation (league-average noise)"
],
"subline": "Some consensus value may remain, but Primary hard gates are not fully cleared.",
"thresholds": {
"extreme_gap_pp": 30.0,
"lean_min_consensus_ev": 0.02,
"lean_min_strength": 5.0,
"min_consensus_ev": 0.05,
"min_execution": 65,
"min_reliability": 65,
"min_strength": 7.0,
"source": "db",
"user_id": 2
},
"thresholds_source": "db",
"thresholds_user_id": 2,
"tier": "observe",
"validation_ok": true,
"value_context": {
"consensus_ev": 0.0014,
"consensus_ev_display": "+0.1%",
"consensus_odds": 3.35,
"disagreement_label": "Moderate",
"disagreement_level": "moderate",
"implied_prob": 0.2792,
"is_extreme_disagreement": false,
"model_prob": 0.353,
"raw_edge_display": "+7.4 percentage points",
"raw_edge_pp": 7.4,
"raw_implied_prob": 0.29850746268656714,
"raw_signal_ev": 0.1825,
"raw_signal_ev_display": "+18.2%"
},
"version": "v2.5",
"xg_calibration": {
"block_value_alert": true,
"calibration_status": "warning",
"deviation_pct": -8.9,
"reasons": [
"Low xG separation gap=0.03 (noise / no edge)"
],
"recommended_action": "monitor",
"strength_delta": -2.0,
"uplift_away": null,
"uplift_home": null,
"xg_separation": {
"band": "flat",
"block_value_alert": true,
"separation_score": -20,
"strength_delta": -2.0,
"xg_gap": 0.03
}
}
},
"headline": "No Primary Bet",
"icon": "\u25cb",
"label": "No Primary Bet",
"subline": "Some consensus value may remain, but Primary hard gates are not fully cleared.",
"tier": "observe"
},
"why": {
"action_line": "Compare model lean with current best odds before sizing any bet.",
"bullets": [
"Model: Athletico Paranaense 1.20 xG vs Atl\u00e9tico-MG 1.23 \u2192 Atl\u00e9tico-MG 35.3%",
"Market Steam: Atl\u00e9tico-MG \u2193 -8.3%"
],
"one_liner": "Model and market both lean Atl\u00e9tico-MG with no major conflict.",
"title": "Why?"
}
},
"edge_rows": [
{
"edge_pp": null,
"fair_prob": 33.86,
"label": "Athletico Paranaense",
"market_prob": null,
"market_type": "1x2",
"outcome": "home"
},
{
"edge_pp": null,
"fair_prob": 30.83,
"label": "Draw",
"market_prob": null,
"market_type": "1x2",
"outcome": "draw"
},
{
"edge_pp": null,
"fair_prob": 35.31,
"label": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"market_prob": null,
"market_type": "1x2",
"outcome": "away"
},
{
"edge_pp": -3.03,
"fair_prob": 43.8,
"label": "Over 2.5",
"market_prob": 46.83,
"market_type": "ou25",
"outcome": "over"
},
{
"edge_pp": 3.03,
"fair_prob": 56.2,
"label": "Under 2.5",
"market_prob": 53.17,
"market_type": "ou25",
"outcome": "under"
},
{
"edge_pp": -1.4,
"fair_prob": 51.1,
"label": "BTTS Yes",
"market_prob": 52.5,
"market_type": "btts",
"outcome": "yes"
},
{
"edge_pp": 1.4,
"fair_prob": 48.9,
"label": "BTTS No",
"market_prob": 47.5,
"market_type": "btts",
"outcome": "no"
}
],
"edge_snapshot": {},
"fair_source": "poisson_pipeline",
"fair_vs_market": {
"closing_capture": "",
"closing_footnote": "Model probabilities are generated from the statistical xG model using a Poisson distribution. Closing market probabilities are derived from consensus closing 1X2 odds after margin removal. Values represent implied probabilities rather than betting recommendations.",
"comparison_available": false,
"comparison_disabled": false,
"comparison_summary": "",
"degraded_note": "",
"divergence_guard": {
"divergence_level": "aligned",
"edge_status": "unknown",
"max_gap_pp": 0.0,
"suppress_hero": false,
"suppress_value_language": false
},
"divergence_label": "",
"divergence_level": "aligned",
"divergence_level_label": "Aligned",
"divergence_note": "",
"divergence_tier": "aligned",
"edge_label": "",
"edge_label_key": "",
"fair_confidence": "medium",
"fair_confidence_label": "Medium",
"fair_source_note": "Model probabilities are generated from the statistical xG model using a Poisson distribution. Closing market probabilities are derived from consensus closing 1X2 odds after margin removal. Values represent implied probabilities rather than betting recommendations.",
"forecast_assessment": {
"favourite_class": "Balanced match",
"favourite_label": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"forecast_certainty_tier": "low",
"headline": "Balanced match",
"market_agreement_label": "\u2014",
"market_direction": {
"label": "Supports model direction",
"positive": true
},
"market_prob_pct": 27.9,
"model_prob_gap_display": "+7.4 percentage points",
"model_prob_gap_pp": 7.4,
"model_prob_pct": 35.3,
"outcome_separation_tier": "low",
"paragraphs": [],
"pricing_convergence": {
"gap_display": "+7.4 percentage points",
"gap_pp": 7.4,
"label": "Moderate",
"label_key": "mi_fa_pricing_moderate"
},
"reliability_headline": "Moderate reliability",
"reliability_icon": "\u2713",
"reliability_score": 69,
"reliability_tier": "moderate",
"summary": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG \u2014 market direction supports the model lean.",
"tier": "balanced",
"title": "Prediction Assessment",
"validation_label": "Pending",
"value_split": {
"execution_confidence": {
"label": "Betting Confidence",
"score": 72,
"tier": "high",
"tier_label": "High"
},
"market_compatibility": {
"label": "Pricing proximity (inverse gap)",
"note": "This score falls as the probability gap (pp) rises \u2014 it is NOT a bet green light. Direction may still agree (see Alignment above). Formula: proximity = max(0, 100 \u2212 5\u00d7pp). Example: 16 pp \u2192 20/100 (diverged).",
"score": 63,
"tier": "moderate",
"tier_label": "Moderate"
},
"model_edge_strength": {
"label": "Model Signal Strength",
"score": 35,
"tier": "low",
"tier_label": "Low"
},
"model_value": {
"label": "Pricing proximity (inverse gap)",
"note": "This score falls as the probability gap (pp) rises \u2014 it is NOT a bet green light. Direction may still agree (see Alignment above). Formula: proximity = max(0, 100 \u2212 5\u00d7pp). Example: 16 pp \u2192 20/100 (diverged).",
"score": 63,
"tier": "moderate",
"tier_label": "Moderate"
},
"recommendation": {
"action": "no_bet",
"label": "No Primary Bet"
}
},
"why": {
"action_line": "Compare model lean with current best odds before sizing any bet.",
"bullets": [
"Model: Athletico Paranaense 1.20 xG vs Atl\u00e9tico-MG 1.23 \u2192 Atl\u00e9tico-MG 35.3%",
"Market Steam: Atl\u00e9tico-MG \u2193 -8.3%"
],
"one_liner": "Model and market both lean Atl\u00e9tico-MG with no major conflict.",
"title": "Why?"
}
},
"forecast_certainty": {
"note": "Three outcomes remain closely bunched \u2014 treat as a relatively open match.",
"tier": "low",
"tier_label": "Low"
},
"forecast_certainty_label": "Low",
"has_market_probs": false,
"hero_edge_pp": null,
"hero_label": "",
"hero_side": null,
"market_activity": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG odds shortened \u2193 -8.3%.",
"market_agreement": "unknown",
"market_agreement_label": "\u2014",
"market_interpretation": {},
"market_narrative": {},
"market_source": "closing_1x2",
"max_gap_pp": 0.0,
"model_validation": {
"score_label_key": "mi_mv_pending",
"status": "pending"
},
"model_validation_label": "Pending",
"outcome_separation": {
"breakdown": [
"No outcome exceeds 50% on the 1X2 grid.",
"Top two 1X2 outcomes within 1.5 percentage points."
],
"lead_gap_pp": 1.5,
"max_prob_pct": 35.3,
"note": "How spread out the model 1X2 probabilities are \u2014 crowded splits mean no single outcome dominates. Not accuracy vs the market.",
"tier": "low",
"tier_label": "Low"
},
"outcome_separation_label": "Low",
"overall_assessment": {
"badge_class": "aligned",
"largest_gap_label": "",
"largest_gap_pp": null,
"lead": "The model and closing market are broadly aligned.",
"level": "aligned",
"max_gap_pp": 0.0,
"title": "Broadly Aligned"
},
"rows": [
{
"difference_pp": null,
"edge_pp": null,
"fair_prob_pct": 33.86,
"is_hero": false,
"label": "Athletico Paranaense",
"market_prob_pct": null,
"side": "home",
"signal_key": "",
"signal_label": ""
},
{
"difference_pp": null,
"edge_pp": null,
"fair_prob_pct": 30.83,
"is_hero": false,
"label": "Draw",
"market_prob_pct": null,
"side": "draw",
"signal_key": "",
"signal_label": ""
},
{
"difference_pp": null,
"edge_pp": null,
"fair_prob_pct": 35.31,
"is_hero": false,
"label": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"market_prob_pct": null,
"side": "away",
"signal_key": "",
"signal_label": ""
}
],
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "\u2014",
"steam_note": "",
"unavailable_note": ""
},
"interpretation": {
"has_conflict": "",
"paragraphs": [
"The statistical model leans Atl\u00e9tico-MG (35.3%).",
"However, Atl\u00e9tico-MG has attracted one of the strongest multi-book steam moves of the day (\u2193 -8.3%, 9/10).",
"Atl\u00e9tico-MG \u2014 market direction supports the model lean."
],
"show": true,
"title": "OddsGPT Interpretation"
},
"lifecycle": {
"closing_implied_pct": null,
"closing_odds": null,
"closing_reason": "Expected before kickoff",
"closing_status": "waiting",
"closing_status_label": "Waiting",
"clv_pending": true,
"clv_pp": null,
"clv_reason": "",
"clv_status": "pending",
"context": "match",
"current_stage": "market_monitoring",
"current_stage_detail": "",
"current_stage_label": "Market monitoring",
"entry_implied_pct": 30.3,
"entry_odds": 3.3,
"match_phase": "upcoming",
"match_phase_detail": "",
"match_phase_display": "Upcoming",
"match_phase_label": "Upcoming",
"model_validation_label": "Pending",
"model_validation_status": "pending",
"stages": [
{
"detail": "",
"id": "forecast_generated",
"label": "Prediction Generated",
"status": "done"
},
{
"detail": "",
"id": "market_detected",
"label": "Market Compared",
"status": "active"
},
{
"detail": "",
"id": "model_validated",
"label": "Validation Passed",
"status": "pending"
},
{
"detail": "",
"id": "closing_recorded",
"label": "Closing Recorded",
"status": "pending"
},
{
"detail": "",
"id": "clv_evaluated",
"label": "CLV Evaluated",
"status": "pending"
}
]
},
"market_move_intelligence": {
"books_reacting": 9,
"books_reacting_detail": [
{
"bookmaker_id": 32,
"bookmaker_name": "Betano",
"is_sharp": false,
"move_delta_display": "\u2193 -16.5%",
"odds_delta_pct": -16.5
},
{
"bookmaker_id": 7,
"bookmaker_name": "William Hill",
"is_sharp": false,
"move_delta_display": "\u2193 -11.4%",
"odds_delta_pct": -11.4
},
{
"bookmaker_id": 11,
"bookmaker_name": "1xBet",
"is_sharp": false,
"move_delta_display": "\u2193 -10.9%",
"odds_delta_pct": -10.9
},
{
"bookmaker_id": 2,
"bookmaker_name": "Marathonbet",
"is_sharp": false,
"move_delta_display": "\u2193 -10.9%",
"odds_delta_pct": -10.9
},
{
"bookmaker_id": 4,
"bookmaker_name": "Pinnacle",
"is_sharp": true,
"move_delta_display": "\u2193 -10.1%",
"odds_delta_pct": -10.1
},
{
"bookmaker_id": 8,
"bookmaker_name": "Bet365",
"is_sharp": true,
"move_delta_display": "\u2193 -8.3%",
"odds_delta_pct": -8.3
},
{
"bookmaker_id": 36,
"bookmaker_name": "BetVictor",
"is_sharp": false,
"move_delta_display": "\u2193 -8.3%",
"odds_delta_pct": -8.3
},
{
"bookmaker_id": 3,
"bookmaker_name": "Betfair",
"is_sharp": true,
"move_delta_display": "\u2193 -5.6%",
"odds_delta_pct": -5.6
},
{
"bookmaker_id": 5,
"bookmaker_name": "SBO",
"is_sharp": true,
"move_delta_display": "\u2193 -3.5%",
"odds_delta_pct": -3.5
}
],
"books_total": 10,
"breadth_display": "9/10",
"clv_label": "Waiting for Close",
"clv_status": "waiting",
"current_odds": 3.3,
"is_drift": false,
"move_context": "Largest move today",
"move_display": "\u2193 -8.3%",
"move_pct_abs": 8.3,
"move_speed_icon": "\ud83d\udc22",
"move_speed_label": "Slow drift over 151h 58m",
"narrative_paragraphs": [
"Multi-book steam on Atl\u00e9tico-MG (8.3%, 9/10) \u2014 aligned shortening, not a single-book blip.",
"Sharper sportsbooks initiated a solid move with growing cross-book confirmation."
],
"narrative_title": "Market Narrative",
"odds_delta_pct": -8.3,
"odds_path": {
"chart_y_labels": [
"3.60",
"3.45",
"3.30"
],
"display": "3.96 \u2192 3.04 \u2192 3.30",
"move_speed_icon": "\ud83d\udc22",
"move_speed_label": "Slow drift over 151h 58m",
"pick_team": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"points": [
{
"label_key": "open",
"value": "3.96"
},
{
"label_key": "extreme",
"value": "3.04"
},
{
"label_key": "current",
"value": "3.30"
}
],
"sparkline_points": [
3.6,
3.3
],
"sparkline_polyline": "0.0,0.0 56.0,18.0",
"sparkline_trend": "down",
"sparkline_trend_label": "One-way drop",
"summary_boxes": [
{
"label_key": "open",
"value": "3.60"
},
{
"label_key": "low",
"value": "3.30"
},
{
"label_key": "high",
"value": "3.60"
},
{
"label_key": "current",
"value": "3.30"
}
]
},
"open_odds": 3.6,
"page_alert_line": "Sharp money alert: Atl\u00e9tico-MG \u2193 -8.3% market move detected",
"phase_label": "Sharp repricing",
"phase_tip": "Aggressive adjustment \u2014 often sharp-led or high consensus.",
"pick_team": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"ref_book": "Bet365",
"seo_title_alert": "Sharp money alert: Atl\u00e9tico-MG \u2193 -8.3% market move detected",
"sharp_leader": "Pinnacle",
"show": true,
"signal_badge_class": "confirm",
"signal_icon": "\ud83d\udcc8",
"signal_impact": {
"current_odds": 3.3,
"is_drift": false,
"label": "Sharp signal",
"move_display": "\u2193 -8.3%",
"open_odds": 3.6,
"summary": "Sharp money supports the same direction as the model lean.",
"team": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"tone": "with"
},
"signal_key": "market_steam",
"signal_label": "Steam",
"steam_score": 61,
"steam_subtitle": "Strong sharp signal",
"steam_tier": "A",
"title": "Market Move Intelligence"
},
"market_overview": {
"breadth_display": "9/10",
"current_odds": 3.3,
"move_display": "\u2193 -8.3%",
"open_odds": 3.6,
"pick_team": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"steam_score": 61,
"steam_team_name": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"steam_tier": "A"
},
"premium_teaser": {},
"show": true
},
"match": {
"at2.away_team_slug": "atletico-mg",
"away_expected_goals": null,
"away_goal_display": null,
"away_team_display_name": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"away_team_id": 1062,
"away_team_logo": "/static/teams/1062.webp",
"away_team_name": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"away_team_public_id": "4coFW7kcWn8wav",
"away_team_slug": "atletico-mg",
"country_code": "BR",
"country_display_name": "Brazil",
"country_flag": "/static/images/country/br.svg",
"country_id": 24,
"country_name": "Brazil",
"fixture_id": 1492390,
"goals_away": null,
"goals_home": null,
"home_expected_goals": null,
"home_goal_display": null,
"home_team_country": "Brazil",
"home_team_display_name": "Athletico Paranaense",
"home_team_id": 134,
"home_team_logo": "/static/teams/134.webp",
"home_team_name": "Athletico Paranaense",
"home_team_public_id": "4PvGbDJnML5mhQ",
"home_team_slug": "atletico-paranaense",
"ht.home_team_slug": "atletico-paranaense",
"league_country": "Brazil",
"league_country_display": "Brazil",
"league_display_name": "Serie A Brazil",
"league_id": 71,
"league_logo": "/static/leagues/71.webp",
"league_name": "Serie A Brazil",
"league_public_id": "0wg055kq66Q9K5",
"league_season": 2026,
"match_date": "2026-10-08 23:00:00",
"public_id": "0ZZ0Oumq5FySFO",
"score_fulltime_away": null,
"score_fulltime_home": null,
"score_penalty_away": null,
"score_penalty_home": null,
"status_long": "Not Started",
"status_short": "NS",
"venue_city": "Curitiba",
"venue_name": "Arena da Baixada"
},
"match_decision": {
"confidence": {
"breakdown": [
"pred_conf_md_max_1x2_under_50",
"pred_conf_md_top_two_close",
"pred_conf_md_line_above_ev",
"pred_conf_md_xg_borderline",
"pred_conf_md_draw_above_30"
],
"breakdown_resolved": [
"Max 1X2 prob under 50% (open contest) (\u22121.0)",
"Top two outcomes relatively close in probability (\u22120.5)",
"At least one tracked line above +EV threshold (+0.5)",
"Total xG in borderline band (high variance) (\u22121.5)",
"Draw probability above 30% (\u22120.5)"
],
"score": 4.0
},
"markets": {
"1x2": {
"1x2_ev_mode": "market_first_p15",
"away": {
"alpha": 0.2668,
"best_odd": 3.35,
"calibration": {
"active": false,
"hook": "CALIBRATE_1X2_P_FINAL"
},
"edge": 0.0197,
"ev": 0.0014,
"implied_prob": 0.2792,
"joint_probs": {
"away": 0.2792,
"draw": 0.2956,
"home": 0.4252
},
"model_prob": 0.353,
"p_final": 0.2989
},
"draw": {
"alpha": 0.2942,
"best_odd": 3.165,
"calibration": {
"active": false,
"hook": "CALIBRATE_1X2_P_FINAL"
},
"edge": 0.0038,
"ev": -0.0527,
"implied_prob": 0.2956,
"joint_probs": {
"away": 0.2792,
"draw": 0.2956,
"home": 0.4252
},
"model_prob": 0.3083,
"p_final": 0.2993
},
"ev_available": true,
"home": {
"alpha": 0.3916,
"best_odd": 2.2,
"calibration": {
"active": false,
"hook": "CALIBRATE_1X2_P_FINAL"
},
"edge": -0.0339,
"ev": -0.1391,
"implied_prob": 0.4252,
"joint_probs": {
"away": 0.2792,
"draw": 0.2956,
"home": 0.4252
},
"model_prob": 0.3387,
"p_final": 0.3913
}
},
"1x2_outlier": {
"1x2_ev_mode": "legacy_max_odd",
"away": {
"best_odd": 3.65,
"edge": 0.079,
"ev": 0.2885,
"implied_prob": 0.274,
"model_prob": 0.353
},
"draw": {
"best_odd": 3.35,
"edge": 0.0098,
"ev": 0.0329,
"implied_prob": 0.2985,
"model_prob": 0.3083
},
"ev_available": true,
"home": {
"best_odd": 2.3,
"edge": -0.0961,
"ev": -0.2211,
"implied_prob": 0.4348,
"model_prob": 0.3387
}
},
"btts": {
"alpha_no": 0.3438,
"alpha_yes": 0.3782,
"best_no_odd": 2.1,
"best_yes_odd": 1.8,
"btts_ev_mode": "market_first_available",
"edge_no": 0.014,
"edge_yes": -0.014,
"ev_available": true,
"ev_no": 0.0269,
"ev_no_risk_adj": -0.064,
"ev_yes": -0.0802,
"ev_yes_risk_adj": -0.0799,
"implied_no": 0.475,
"implied_yes": 0.525,
"market_first": {
"available": true,
"mode": "market_first_btts",
"n_bookmakers": 7,
"no": {
"alpha": 0.3438,
"best_odd": 1.945,
"edge": 0.0041,
"ev": -0.064,
"implied_prob": 0.4772,
"model_prob": 0.489,
"p_final": 0.4812
},
"prediction_confidence": "low",
"yes": {
"alpha": 0.3782,
"best_odd": 1.775,
"edge": -0.0045,
"ev": -0.0799,
"implied_prob": 0.5228,
"model_prob": 0.511,
"p_final": 0.5184
}
},
"n_bookmakers": 7,
"p_final_no": 0.4812,
"p_final_yes": 0.5184,
"prediction_confidence": "low",
"reliability": "medium"
},
"ou25": {
"alpha_over": 0.3486,
"alpha_under": 0.3835,
"best_over_odd": 2.08,
"best_under_odd": 1.83,
"consensus_over_odd": 2.0,
"consensus_under_odd": 1.79,
"edge_over": -0.0303,
"edge_under": 0.0303,
"ev_available": true,
"ev_over": -0.089,
"ev_over_risk_adj": -0.0793,
"ev_under": 0.0285,
"ev_under_risk_adj": -0.0319,
"implied_over": 0.4683,
"implied_over_mf": 0.4723,
"implied_under": 0.5317,
"implied_under_mf": 0.5277,
"market_first": {
"available": true,
"mode": "market_first_ou",
"n_bookmakers": 8,
"over": {
"alpha": 0.3486,
"best_odd": 2.0,
"edge": -0.012,
"ev": -0.0793,
"implied_prob": 0.4723,
"model_prob": 0.438,
"p_final": 0.4603
},
"prediction_confidence": "low",
"under": {
"alpha": 0.3835,
"best_odd": 1.79,
"edge": 0.0132,
"ev": -0.0319,
"implied_prob": 0.5277,
"model_prob": 0.562,
"p_final": 0.5409
}
},
"n_bookmakers": 8,
"ou_ev_mode": "market_first_available",
"p_final_over": 0.4603,
"p_final_under": 0.5409,
"prediction_confidence": "low",
"reliability": "medium"
}
},
"match_regime": {
"action": "avoid",
"code": "no_edge",
"execution_line_key": "pred_regime_exec_no_actionable",
"insight_line_key": "pred_regime_insight_minor_inefficiency",
"stake_mult": 0.0,
"use_split_strip": true
},
"match_tier": "no_bet",
"min_ev": 0.02,
"total_xg": 2.43,
"variance_flag": true
},
"unified_decision": {
"actionable_ev_threshold": 0.02,
"algorithm": {
"enabled_since": "2026-05-26",
"game_typing_module": true,
"version": "2.5.0"
},
"balanced_alternative": null,
"best_consensus_ev": 0.0285,
"best_outlier_ev": 0.2885,
"best_tracked_ev": 0.0285,
"confidence": 4.0,
"decision_confidence_v1": {
"breakdown": [
"pred_conf_v1_max_1x2_under_50",
"pred_conf_v1_draw_above_30",
"pred_conf_v1_multi_ev_lines"
],
"breakdown_resolved": [
"Max 1X2 prob under 50% (no dominant 1X2) (\u22121.0)",
"Draw probability above 30% (\u22120.5)",
"Two or more valid +EV lines at threshold (+0.5)"
],
"breakdown_v2": [
"Base decision score (v1)",
"Reliability supports action",
"Market aligns with model",
"Thin consensus value",
"Low xG separation (league-average noise)"
],
"score": 3.5,
"score_v1_legacy": 4.0,
"score_v2_pre_penalty": 5.5,
"strength_v2": true
},
"decision_strength_v2": {
"breakdown": [
"Base decision score (v1)",
"Reliability supports action",
"Market aligns with model",
"Thin consensus value",
"Low xG separation (league-average noise)"
],
"score": 3.5,
"score_pre_penalty": 5.5
},
"decision_type": "NO_SIGNAL",
"execution": {
"1x2_dominant": false,
"1x2_open_contest": true,
"grade": "C",
"stake_factor": 0.0
},
"favourite_misaligned_1x2": {
"active": false,
"gap": null,
"side": null
},
"final_action": "no_bet",
"final_decision": {
"action": "no_bet",
"alignment": {
"direction_aligned": true,
"direction_key": "agree",
"gap_pp": 7.4,
"key": "agree",
"label": "Agree",
"model_strong": false,
"pricing_aligned": true,
"pricing_key": "moderate",
"probability_gap_pp": 7.4,
"summary": "Model and market currently agree on the stronger side (Atl\u00e9tico-MG)."
},
"alignment_key": "agree",
"best_consensus_ev": 0.0285,
"best_outlier_ev": 0.2885,
"confidence_band": "Moderate\u2013Low",
"decision_strength": 3.5,
"decision_strength_v1": 4.0,
"decision_strength_v2": 5.5,
"decision_type": "NO_SIGNAL",
"execution_confidence": 72,
"extreme_disagreement": false,
"final_verdict_audit": {
"action": "Monitor closing market and validate with CLV.",
"action_label": "Action",
"decision": "No Primary Bet",
"is_primary": false,
"snapshot": "The Decision Model estimates Atl\u00e9tico-MG at 35.3%, compared with a no-vig market probability of 27.9%.",
"why": [
{
"text": "Decision Model identifies Atl\u00e9tico-MG as the value side (35.3%)",
"tone": "ok"
},
{
"text": "Market broadly agrees with the direction",
"tone": "ok"
},
{
"text": "Market quality / price reliability is insufficient for Primary",
"tone": "bad"
},
{
"text": "Edge does not clear Primary threshold",
"tone": "bad"
},
{
"text": "Model confidence reduced due to calibration uncertainty",
"tone": "bad"
}
],
"why_label": "Decision Summary"
},
"gap_pp": 7.4,
"gates_failed": [
"No consensus-line +EV at Primary threshold"
],
"has_top_pick": false,
"headline": "No Primary Bet",
"hero_mode": "default",
"icon": "\u25cb",
"label": "No Primary Bet",
"market_signal": "Market aligns with model lean",
"model_conflict_detail": null,
"model_lean": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"no_primary_reasons": {
"all_triggered": [
"market_quality",
"edge_low",
"calibration_risk"
],
"calibration_mode": "soft",
"codes": [
"market_quality",
"edge_low"
],
"label": "Reason",
"other_factors": [
{
"code": "edge_low",
"detail": "The estimated edge does not meet the Primary threshold.",
"name": "Edge Below Threshold",
"short": "Edge Below Threshold",
"tone": "neutral"
}
],
"other_label": "Other factors",
"primary": {
"code": "market_quality",
"detail": "Price reliability is weak (thin coverage, outlier quote, or low book agreement).",
"name": "Market Quality Risk",
"short": "Market Quality Risk",
"tone": "warn"
},
"secondary": {
"code": "edge_low",
"detail": "The estimated edge does not meet the Primary threshold.",
"name": "Edge Below Threshold",
"short": "Edge Below Threshold",
"tone": "neutral"
},
"version": "v1"
},
"outlier_detected": true,
"outlier_excluded_panel": "Excluded top quotes (audit row \u2014 never Primary): #1 \u00b7 market 1X2 \u00b7 side Atl\u00e9tico-MG \u00b7 decimal odds ~3.80 (derived from model% \u00d7 (1+EV)) \u00b7 EV +29% \u00b7 book: not captured on live render (see odds history / admin snapshot) \u00b7 captured: \u2014 \u00b7 audit_ref: fixture=1492390 \u00b7 snapshot=live-render \u00b7 odds\u22483.80 \u00b7 reason=thin|single-book|\u0394EV\u22653.0%EV \u00b7 book=admin-only \u00b7 trigger: outlier EV \u2212 consensus EV \u2265 +3.0% EV (not probability pp) AND thin/single-book style \u00b7 consensus used +2.9% EV. Excluded quotes cannot clear Primary.",
"primary_allowed": false,
"primary_block_explain": {
"entries": [
{
"key": "weak_ev",
"label": "Consensus EV +2.9% \u003c Primary gate +5.0% (Lean gate +2.0% is separate \u2014 not Primary)",
"ok": false
},
{
"key": "gate",
"label": "No consensus-line +EV at Primary threshold",
"ok": false
}
],
"lean_ev_threshold_pct": 2.0,
"primary_ev_threshold_pct": 5.0,
"subtitle": "Primary needs consensus EV \u2265 +5.0% plus reliability/execution/calibration gates (Decision Strength is explain-only). Lean/tracked gate is +2.0% (selective only \u2014 not default Primary sizing).",
"title": "Why not Primary?"
},
"primary_gate_checklist": "Gate checklist: Consensus EV +2.9% \u274c (need \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration See checklist \u274c \u2192 Primary blocked. Decision Strength 3.5/10 (explain only, not a Primary gate). If you still act under hard block: example stake 0.10\u20130.20% bankroll (never Primary).",
"primary_gate_snapshot": "Primary Gate Snapshot: Consensus EV +2.9% (gate \u2265+5.0%) \u00b7 Calibration: See checklist \u2192 Primary blocked \u00b7 Decision Strength 3.5/10 (display only)",
"primary_gates": {
"items": [
{
"key": "extreme_gap",
"label": "Extreme gap",
"ok": true,
"value": "no"
},
{
"key": "xg_calibration",
"label": "xG calibration",
"ok": true,
"value": "warning"
},
{
"key": "reliability",
"label": "Rel",
"ok": true,
"value": "69 (\u226565)"
},
{
"key": "execution",
"label": "Exec",
"ok": true,
"value": "72 (\u226565)"
},
{
"key": "alignment",
"label": "Align",
"ok": true,
"value": "agree"
},
{
"key": "consensus_ev",
"label": "ConsEV",
"ok": false,
"value": "+2.9% (\u2265+5.0%)"
},
{
"key": "top_pick",
"label": "Pick",
"ok": false,
"value": "false"
},
{
"key": "validation",
"label": "Validation",
"ok": true,
"value": "true"
}
],
"passed": 6,
"total": 8
},
"primary_type": null,
"reasons": [
"Model and market currently agree on the stronger side (Atl\u00e9tico-MG).",
"Decision strength: 3.5/10",
"No consensus-line +EV at Primary threshold",
"Outlier price +29% EV detected \u2014 not used for Primary (consensus only)."
],
"reliability_score": 69,
"speed_read": "Speed read: Model Signal can look moderate/strong while Decision Strength stays low after calibration \u2014 Strength alone does not block Primary (v2.5+); still check reliability/execution/EV hard gates.",
"strength_v2_breakdown": [
"Base decision score (v1)",
"Reliability supports action",
"Market aligns with model",
"Thin consensus value",
"Low xG separation (league-average noise)"
],
"subline": "Some consensus value may remain, but Primary hard gates are not fully cleared.",
"thresholds": {
"extreme_gap_pp": 30.0,
"lean_min_consensus_ev": 0.02,
"lean_min_strength": 5.0,
"min_consensus_ev": 0.05,
"min_execution": 65,
"min_reliability": 65,
"min_strength": 7.0,
"source": "db",
"user_id": 2
},
"thresholds_source": "db",
"thresholds_user_id": 2,
"tier": "observe",
"validation_ok": true,
"value_context": {
"consensus_ev": 0.0014,
"consensus_ev_display": "+0.1%",
"consensus_odds": 3.35,
"disagreement_label": "Moderate",
"disagreement_level": "moderate",
"implied_prob": 0.2792,
"is_extreme_disagreement": false,
"model_prob": 0.353,
"raw_edge_display": "+7.4 percentage points",
"raw_edge_pp": 7.4,
"raw_implied_prob": 0.29850746268656714,
"raw_signal_ev": 0.1825,
"raw_signal_ev_display": "+18.2%"
},
"version": "v2.5",
"xg_calibration": {
"block_value_alert": true,
"calibration_status": "warning",
"deviation_pct": -8.9,
"reasons": [
"Low xG separation gap=0.03 (noise / no edge)"
],
"recommended_action": "monitor",
"strength_delta": -2.0,
"uplift_away": null,
"uplift_home": null,
"xg_separation": {
"band": "flat",
"block_value_alert": true,
"separation_score": -20,
"strength_delta": -2.0,
"xg_gap": 0.03
}
}
},
"game_type": {
"label_zh": "\u5747\u8861\uff08\u5f00\u653e\u8d5b\u679c\uff09",
"scoring_type": "balanced",
"signals": {
"btts_yes_prob": 0.511,
"draw_prob": 0.3083,
"max_1x2_prob": 0.353,
"over_prob": 0.438,
"total_xg": 2.43,
"under_prob": 0.562,
"xg_diff": 0.03
},
"type": "balanced",
"typing_weights_enabled": true
},
"hero_display_pick": {
"decision": "small_edge",
"ev": 0.0285,
"hero_display_only": true,
"implied_prob": 0.5317,
"market": "ou_2_5",
"model_prob": 0.562,
"not_dominant": false,
"risk_band": "strong",
"risk_tier": "hero_display",
"side": "under",
"slot": "hero_display"
},
"hero_mode": "default",
"longshot_picks": [],
"markets": {
"1x2": {
"consensus_odds": 3.35,
"decision": "small_edge",
"edge": 0.0197,
"ev": 0.0014,
"implied_prob": 0.2792,
"max_ev_side": "away",
"model_prob": 0.353,
"side": "away",
"side_label": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG"
},
"btts": {
"decision": "small_edge",
"decision_layer": {
"alpha": 0.3438,
"available": true,
"consensus_odds": 1.945,
"edge": 0.0041,
"market_prob": 0.4772,
"mode": "market_first_btts",
"model_prob": 0.489,
"n_bookmakers": 7,
"no": {
"alpha": 0.3438,
"best_odd": 1.945,
"edge": 0.0041,
"ev": -0.064,
"implied_prob": 0.4772,
"model_prob": 0.489,
"p_final": 0.4812
},
"p_final": 0.4812,
"prediction_confidence": "low",
"risk_adj_ev": -0.064,
"value_side": "no",
"yes": {
"alpha": 0.3782,
"best_odd": 1.775,
"edge": -0.0045,
"ev": -0.0799,
"implied_prob": 0.5228,
"model_prob": 0.511,
"p_final": 0.5184
}
},
"edge": 0.014,
"ev": 0.0269,
"implied_prob": 0.475,
"model_prob": 0.489,
"side": "no",
"value_side": "no"
},
"ou_2_5": {
"decision": "small_edge",
"decision_layer": {
"alpha": 0.3835,
"available": true,
"consensus_odds": 1.79,
"edge": 0.0132,
"market_prob": 0.5277,
"mode": "market_first_ou",
"model_prob": 0.562,
"n_bookmakers": 8,
"over": {
"alpha": 0.3486,
"best_odd": 2.0,
"edge": -0.012,
"ev": -0.0793,
"implied_prob": 0.4723,
"model_prob": 0.438,
"p_final": 0.4603
},
"p_final": 0.5409,
"prediction_confidence": "low",
"risk_adj_ev": -0.0319,
"under": {
"alpha": 0.3835,
"best_odd": 1.79,
"edge": 0.0132,
"ev": -0.0319,
"implied_prob": 0.5277,
"model_prob": 0.562,
"p_final": 0.5409
},
"value_side": "under"
},
"edge": 0.0303,
"ev": 0.0285,
"implied_prob": 0.5317,
"model_prob": 0.562,
"side": "under",
"value_side": "under"
}
},
"match_id": 1492390,
"match_regime": {
"action": "optional",
"actionable": false,
"clear_edge": false,
"code": "thin_edge",
"execution_line_key": "pred_regime_exec_no_actionable",
"insight_line_key": "pred_regime_insight_minor_inefficiency",
"max_valid_ev": 0.0285,
"min_ev": 0.02,
"stake_mult": 0.25,
"use_split_strip": true
},
"match_tier": "value_game",
"no_clear_primary": false,
"probabilities": {
"away": 0.353,
"draw": 0.3083,
"home": 0.3387
},
"reason_codes": [
"variance_medium"
],
"secondary_pick": null,
"secondary_picks": [],
"show_betting_primary_label": false,
"suppressed_primary": null,
"teams": {
"away": "Atl\u00e9tico-MG",
"home": "Athletico Paranaense"
},
"top_pick": null,
"valid_markets_count": 2,
"value_context_1x2": {
"consensus_ev": 0.0014,
"consensus_ev_display": "+0.1%",
"consensus_odds": 3.35,
"disagreement_label": "Moderate",
"disagreement_level": "moderate",
"implied_prob": 0.2792,
"is_extreme_disagreement": false,
"model_prob": 0.353,
"raw_edge_display": "+7.4 percentage points",
"raw_edge_pp": 7.4,
"raw_implied_prob": 0.29850746268656714,
"raw_signal_ev": 0.1825,
"raw_signal_ev_display": "+18.2%"
}
}
},
"fixture_id": 1492390,
"generated_at_utc": "2026-10-08T19:21:56.713353+00:00",
"lang_id": "en"
}
Terokai Kandungan Ramalan Lain
Dapatkan Ramalan Premium untuk Athletico Paranaense & Atlético-MG!
Buka analisis mendalam, tip pertaruhan eksklusif, dan ramalan perlawanan dengan perkhidmatan langganan premium kami.
Langgan Sekarang
Serie A Brazil — Kedudukan
| # | PASUKAN | P | M | S | K | Mata |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Flamengo | 29 | 18 | 7 | 4 | 61 |
| 2 | Palmeiras | 28 | 16 | 9 | 3 | 57 |
| 3 | Athletico Paranaense | 28 | 14 | 7 | 7 | 49 |
| 4 | Cruzeiro | 29 | 14 | 6 | 9 | 48 |
| 5 | Fluminense | 28 | 13 | 9 | 6 | 48 |
| 6 | Bahia | 28 | 12 | 10 | 6 | 46 |
| 7 | Atlético-MG | 28 | 12 | 7 | 9 | 43 |
| 8 | Santos | 29 | 11 | 9 | 9 | 42 |
| 9 | Coritiba | 28 | 10 | 8 | 10 | 38 |
| 10 | RB Bragantino | 29 | 10 | 7 | 12 | 37 |
| 11 | São Paulo | 29 | 10 | 6 | 13 | 36 |
| 12 | Vitória | 29 | 10 | 6 | 13 | 36 |
| 13 | Botafogo | 29 | 9 | 8 | 12 | 35 |
| 14 | Vasco da Gama | 28 | 9 | 7 | 12 | 34 |
| 15 | Mirassol | 29 | 8 | 9 | 12 | 33 |
| 16 | Corinthians | 29 | 8 | 8 | 13 | 32 |
| 17 | Internacional | 29 | 7 | 10 | 12 | 31 |
| 18 | Gremio | 29 | 7 | 9 | 13 | 30 |
| 19 | Remo | 29 | 5 | 9 | 15 | 24 |
| 20 | Chapecoense | 28 | 3 | 9 | 16 | 18 |
| 20 | Chapecoense B | 20 | 1 | 7 | 12 | 10 |
| # | PASUKAN | P | J | B | +/- | Mata |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Flamengo | 29 | 57 | 25 | +32 | 61 |
| 2 | Palmeiras | 28 | 47 | 21 | +26 | 57 |
| 3 | Santos | 29 | 45 | 43 | +2 | 42 |
| 4 | Fluminense | 28 | 44 | 36 | +8 | 48 |
| 5 | Cruzeiro | 29 | 44 | 40 | +4 | 48 |
| 6 | Athletico Paranaense | 28 | 43 | 32 | +11 | 49 |
| 7 | Bahia | 28 | 43 | 35 | +8 | 46 |
| 8 | Botafogo | 29 | 42 | 47 | -5 | 35 |
| 9 | Atlético-MG | 28 | 37 | 32 | +5 | 43 |
| 10 | Coritiba | 28 | 37 | 43 | -6 | 38 |
| 11 | Vasco da Gama | 28 | 36 | 42 | -6 | 34 |
| 12 | RB Bragantino | 29 | 34 | 33 | +1 | 37 |
| 13 | Mirassol | 29 | 34 | 43 | -9 | 33 |
| 14 | São Paulo | 29 | 33 | 34 | -1 | 36 |
| 15 | Remo | 29 | 33 | 48 | -15 | 24 |
| 16 | Internacional | 29 | 32 | 37 | -5 | 31 |
| 17 | Vitória | 29 | 32 | 42 | -10 | 36 |
| 18 | Gremio | 29 | 31 | 39 | -8 | 30 |
| 19 | Corinthians | 29 | 30 | 34 | -4 | 32 |
| 20 | Chapecoense | 28 | 29 | 57 | -28 | 18 |
| 21 | Chapecoense B | 20 | 19 | 41 | -22 | 10 |
| # | PASUKAN | P | xG | xGC | +/- | Mata |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bahia | 28 | 12.2 | 6.9 | +5.3 | 46 |
| 2 | Santos | 29 | 9.9 | 6.6 | +3.3 | 42 |
| 3 | Flamengo | 29 | 9.0 | 5.7 | +3.3 | 61 |
| 4 | Vasco da Gama | 28 | 9.2 | 6.1 | +3.1 | 34 |
| 5 | Atlético-MG | 28 | 5.9 | 2.9 | +3.0 | 43 |
| 6 | Corinthians | 29 | 7.2 | 4.7 | +2.5 | 32 |
| 7 | Athletico Paranaense | 28 | 10.2 | 8.1 | +2.1 | 49 |
| 8 | Fluminense | 28 | 8.7 | 6.8 | +1.9 | 48 |
| 9 | Palmeiras | 28 | 8.2 | 6.5 | +1.7 | 57 |
| 10 | Botafogo | 29 | 11.0 | 10.9 | +0.1 | 35 |
| 11 | São Paulo | 29 | 4.9 | 4.8 | +0.1 | 36 |
| 12 | RB Bragantino | 29 | 4.9 | 5.7 | -0.8 | 37 |
| 13 | Cruzeiro | 29 | 9.3 | 10.2 | -0.9 | 48 |
| 14 | Mirassol | 29 | 7.1 | 9.0 | -1.9 | 33 |
| 15 | Remo | 29 | 5.6 | 7.7 | -2.1 | 24 |
| 16 | Coritiba | 28 | 4.9 | 7.1 | -2.2 | 38 |
| 17 | Chapecoense | 28 | 7.3 | 9.9 | -2.6 | 18 |
| 18 | Internacional | 29 | 8.8 | 11.5 | -2.7 | 31 |
| 19 | Vitória | 29 | 6.6 | 11.7 | -5.1 | 36 |
| 20 | Gremio | 29 | 5.3 | 13.5 | -8.2 | 30 |
| 21 | Chapecoense B | 20 | — | — | — | 10 |